dooce.com - August 2008
Grayonblackrule Heather
  • Daily PhotoNav Dailyphoto
  • Daily Chuck
    Nav Dailychuck
  • Daily StyleNav Dailystyle

Grayonblackrule

Please be patient with me

File Under: Daily

Another busy week here at the Blurbodoocery involving doctors appointments, travel, vet visits, and a multitude of concerts. Tonight we're attending the sold out Wilco concert where the Fleet Foxes will be opening, and it's at my favorite outdoor venue in the city. If you're not familiar with either band, here's an introduction to the Fleet Foxes:


And here's Jeff Tweedy from Wilco playing an acoustic version of the soundtrack to my marriage to Jon:


This weekend we're headed to San Francisco to the Outside Lands Festival, a three-day music event at Golden Gate Park (look at that lineup and be very jealous of me). While I'm there I'll be posting photos and whatnot here and at the community site Crowdfire where they are giving away free tickets to the festival every day. Friday night I will get to see Radiohead for the tenth time, and maybe I will finally get up the nerve up to throw my panties at guitarist Ed O'Brien who happens to be number two on my Five Fame Fuckers list.

Interestingly, recent international events have brought to my attention a certain special someone who has so stolen my heart that he has knocked off two of the previous men on my list and now occupies both of those positions. So my list now looks like this:

1. Chris Martin
2. Ed O'Brien
3. Brad Pitt
4. Michael Phelps
5. Michael Phelps

I brought up this development the other night with a group of friends, and the men in the group were all, BUT HIS EARS! AND THAT UNDERBITE! Which of course was exactly how I expected them to respond, all of their lists are comprised entirely of supermodels. I think his ears are adorable, and that mouth of his is interesting, but the list really has very little to do with appearance and everything to do with the overall package. Are they driven? Do they care about people? What is their take on certain issues? Are they bigger than I am? Do they know their multiplication tables? Also, good hair helps. And yes, I will be honest and say that the way Michael Phelps fits into a wetsuit is very pleasing to look upon with my eyes.

Don't worry, Jon has his own list, and if we were at a concert where Renee Russo was playing the guitar, I would take off Jon's briefs and throw them at her head for him. That was written into our vows.

Your list?

899 comments
  • 1. Kylee said:

    1. John Krasinski
    2. John Krasinski

  • 2. Courtenay said:

    whew, just as i found you and started reading i thought you disappeared! i agree, yay for michael phelps...and he used to be a nerd so it allll comes around! looking foward to the latest on chuck..

  • 3. Klem said:

    - Eve Libertine
    - James Marsters
    - Garrett Wang
    - Billy Idol
    - Johnny Rotten

  • 4. Melissa said:

    1. Hugh Jackman
    2. Eddie Vedder
    3. Hugh Jackman
    4. Ryan Reynolds
    5. Hugh Jackman

  • 5. kjkc said:

    Though Phelps is a hottie... unfortunately the other day he went on and on and on about the greatness of George W... what a wonderful president he is... INSTANT turnoff and removal from list.

  • 6. Tamara Komuniecki said:

    Mine is an interesting combo...I like to cover all the bases.

    1. Michael Phelps
    2. Benjamin Netanyahu
    3. George Clooney
    4. Brad Pitt
    5. Angelina Jolie

  • 7. Emily said:

    1. Christian Bale
    2. Jonny Lang
    3. Paul Newman (when he was in Cool Hand Luke)
    4. Gary Dourdain
    5. Milo Ventiglmia (or whatever)

    P.S. Just looked down and saw that Gilmore was one of the words for verification. Milo was on Gilmore Girls. How cool!

  • 8. Anonymous said:

    No list, but wanted to mention that the west coast debut of Johnny Greenwood's symphony Popcorn Superhet Receiver will be performed in San Francisco on Thursday at the Herbst Theatre.

  • 9. MoxieCrimefighter said:

    1. Brad Pitt
    2. Brad Pitt
    3. Brad Pitt
    4. Eric Roberts (yes...that Eric Roberts!)
    5. Brad Pitt

  • 10. Molly said:

    John Krasinski
    Michael Phelps
    Ryan Reynolds
    John Krasinski
    John Krasinski

  • 11. Jennifer said:

    1. Ryan Gosling
    2. Sam from Top Chef
    3. Brad Pitt (circa Fight Club)
    4. Matthew Fox
    5. Orlando Bloom

  • 12. gingela5 said:

    My list is so messed up it's not even funny...I don't think I have five but my top 3 are:
    1. Bob Stoops (OU's head coach)
    2. "Gil Grissom" (he's about 3 times my age)
    3. Bear Grylls (no explanation needed)

  • 13. Marisa said:

    wow i'm 2nd! :)

    okay my top 5.

    1. Jorge Posada *catcher for the new york yankees*
    2. Sylvester Stallone when he was in Rocky....
    3. Alex Rodriquez
    4. Tony Romo
    5. Jon Bon Jovi

  • 14. Ciara said:

    You are a good woman to throw your husband's unmentionables for him.

    Brad Pitt
    Prince (he is a sexy little man)
    Jude Law
    Justin Timberlake after he grows some hair on his chest

  • 15. Anonymous said:

    I think Chris Martin would be more interested in Jon than you.

  • 16. Annie said:

    1. Michael Johns from American Idol
    2. Robert Downey Jr.
    3. John Malkovich
    4. James Taylor (the way he looked on his Sweet Baby James album cover)
    5. Jude Law (used to be higher on the list until all of his infidelities)

  • 17. Amy said:

    Wow, I'm sooo jealous about Wilco & Fleet Foxes. And Radiohead.

    1.Johnny Depp (I know, how generic but I can't help it)
    2.Jeff Tweedy
    3.Lenny Kravitz (circa 1994)
    4.Brad Pitt
    5.Ed Vedder (only if he doesn't talk)

  • 18. Andreya said:

    i also include angelina jolie on my list. cmon, she is hot.

    then, there are:

    1. adam brody
    2. brad pitt
    3. christian bale
    4. and raine maida.

    mmm yes.

  • 19. Susie said:

    1. Edward Norton
    2. Clive Owen
    3. James McAvoy
    4. Johnny Depp (he's been on here since I was 13 and saw him in Benny & Joon)
    5. Adrien Brody

  • 20. Amber said:

    1. Nick Carter
    2. Chris Martin
    3. Jay Cutler
    4. Jeremy Shockey
    5. Bradley Whitford

    But Phelps is cute. I did a little jump when I found out he won all 8 golds.

  • 21. that girl said:

    Mr. Mustang

    Venicio Del Toro

    Lead singer for Stain'd

    Mc Dreamy

    Ryan Gosselin (sp)

  • 22. Cara said:

    I like to mix it up a bit:

    1) Angelina Jolie
    2) Johnny Depp
    3) Salma Hayek
    4) Kate Winslet
    5) Eddie Vedder/Brian Urlacher (#54 on Chicago Bears)

  • 23. GEORGE! said:

    1: Matt Damon
    2: Will Smith
    3: Brad Pitt
    4: Hugh Jackman
    5: Denzel Washington

    Oh wait... the opposite sex?

  • 24. Amelia Sprout said:

    1. Michael Phelps
    2. Aaron Piersol (nummy, surfer)
    3. Michael Phelps (ears, all the better to steer with)
    4. Henry Rollins
    5. Joseph Fiennes

    And damn him for dying, but Heath Ledger should be on that list. Fucking shame.

  • 25. christina said:

    1. Michael Phelps
    2. Michael Phelps
    3. Michael Phelps
    4. Adrian Brody
    5. Michael Phelps

    He has captured my heart as well.

  • 26. Bex said:

    Hmmm. I am not sure of my top 5 but just watching Michael Phelps do the butterfly is reason enough for him to be on anybodies list. Can you imagine being under that!

  • 27. jennifer said:

    1/ larry mullen jr
    2/ benjamin bratt
    3/ tom colicchio
    4/ daniel day lewis
    5/ jeff probst

  • 28. Lesley said:

    1. Jon Stewart
    2. Matt Damon
    3. Edward Norton
    4. Mathieu Kassovitz
    5. Anderson Cooper (Don't tell me he might be gay; I will not believe you. I plan to bear his articulate, silver-haired children.)

  • 29. Jodi said:

    1. Carey Grant (from when he was in That Touch of Mink)
    2. Gary Sinese
    3. Will Farrell
    4. Timothy Hutton
    5. Vince Vaughn

    eclectic, I know! I am starting to show my age...I would like to throw in a Jesse McCartney or one of the Jonas brothers, but frankly I could be their mother!

  • 30. soulmoxie said:

    Not the Phelps! Have you not seen Ryan Lochte? Sweet Jesus, I have to believe that you would reconsider...

    My list:

    Anderson Cooper
    Christian Bale
    Jon Stewart
    Ryan Lochte
    James Blunt

  • 31. BrooklynSeaHag said:

    1. Christian Bale (oooh, assault me)
    2. Ryan Gosling
    3. Neil Young (but he has to brush his teeth first)
    4. Snoop Dogg
    5. Clive Owen

  • 32. Keely said:

    1. John Cusack
    2. Johnny Depp
    3. David Boreanaz
    4. Glenn Quinn (well, y'know...before he died)
    5. Charlize Theron

  • 33. Kathy said:

    My list:

    1) George Clooney
    2) Robin Ventura (former baseball player - HOT butt)
    3) Sting (even with the ego. Tantric yoga, anyone?)
    4) Colin Firth (Pride & Prejudice era)
    5) George Clooney

    I am SO bummed Olympic swimming is over. How great was that - watching those guys with those bodies? Ahhhhh.

  • 34. Kyle said:

    1) Elijah Wood (it's the eyes!)
    2) Brad Pitt
    3) Andrew Gross, the writer (I refer to him as my boyfriend)
    4) Robert Downey Jr.
    5) Daniel Craig

  • 35. Courtenay said:

    oh, i forgot:

    1. blair underwood
    2. george clooney before he was manorexic
    3. mark ruffalo
    4. sawyer, from lost
    5. blair underwood, again

  • 36. jill said:

    love this. husband and i have a "no other naked people allowed" hot tub rule that we will ONLY break for brad and angelina. and maybe halle and gabriel.

  • 37. Cassie said:

    1. Christopher Meloni
    2. David Boreanaz
    3. Matt Lauer
    4. Sam Waterson
    5. Anthony Bourdain

  • 38. Jenny said:

    Adrien Brody
    John Krasinski
    Michael Phelps
    Ryan Lochte (Michael's swimming friend who got little airtime? HOT!)
    umm....Michael Phelps (he's a dreamboat.

  • 39. Rosemary said:

    In no particular order:

    Bruce Willis (I had a not dream about him and now he's definite)
    Ryan Reynolds
    Slade Smiley from The Real Housewives of Orange County & Date My Ex

    Don't even need 5, these three will do :)
    And I must add that all this "Are they driven? Do they care about people? What is their take on certain issues? Are they bigger than I am? Do they know their multiplication tables?" Doesn't matter in sex! Ok, well the driving and care about people is important. But I don't plan on talking politics or holding a math quiz anytime in my bedroom :)

    Also, Have you heard of etsy?

  • 40. sara said:

    Just wrote a post today about Michael Phelps and the fact that, according to his segment on NBC about a day in his life, we are soulmates. Perfect for each other. And he looks good in a wetsuit.

    So back off. He's totally mine. We're destiny, baby.

    sara

  • 41. Jeff said:

    Wow, so I'm the first guy to post his five? I fully expect scathing ridicule...

    1) Salma Hayek
    2) Angeline Jolie
    3) Evangeline Lilly
    4) Jennifer Carpenter
    5) Melina Perez

  • 42. Pictou said:

    Renee Russo? Like her appearance in the Thomas Crown Affair? Hell, I'd throw MY panties at her and I'm a middle aged woman. As for Michael Phelps, I think he's adorable and needs to take a public speaking class but he's much younger than my daughter so not really turned on by him. But I'm really hyped at all that he's accomplished, I just want to pat him on the head.

  • 43. Anne said:

    1. Tim Riggins (from Friday Night Lights)
    2. Chris Martin (saw amazing show in Chicago)
    3. Johnny Depp
    4. Daniel Day Lewis
    5. Clive Owen

  • 44. J. said:

    I guess my tastes are pretty mundane, comparatively.
    1. Chiwetel Ejiofor
    2. Viggo Mortensen
    3. Jet Li
    4. Jesse L. Martin
    5. John Barrowman
    Yeah, talented actors TURN ME ON.

  • 45. Liz C said:

    Only have a top 3+ right now

    1. Anthony Bourdain
    2. Alton Brown
    3. Matt Damon

    Oh yeah -- Some of the American sprinters I watched this weekend were f-i-n-e!

    I'd say Michael Phelps but he's younger than my daughter. That would be too pervy even for me.

  • 46. Jeff said:

    Whoops...apparently not. Sorry Kyle...

  • 47. Brad said:

    I like my girls smart... so I'll just say that there's only one supermodel on my list, and I don't care if she can't spell her own last name.

  • 48. Ann said:

    1. Ed Harris
    2. Johnny Depp
    6. Michael Symon
    4. Denzel Washington
    5. Vince Vaughn

  • 49. porkmuffin said:

    the list changes. today it's:

    1. Javier Bardem
    2. Clive Owen
    3. Jason Statham
    4. Lee Pace
    5. Naveen Andrews

  • 50. MacDuff said:

    This is so funny. I was just having a conversation with my male coworker about how hot he is. We were flipping through images, with me saying "Look at this one...hot" and he would reply "He looks like a baby who was dropped by his mother," or "He looks intellectually disabled." But I couldn't see it. Then we realized that I had no idea what his face looked like - all I saw was that stomach. And oh lord is it hot.

  • 51. KC said:

    1. Benicio Del Toro
    2. John Leguizamo
    3. Brad Pitt
    4. Benicio Del Toro
    5. Benicio Del Toro

  • 52. petri dish said:

    you've got to check out M. Ward while you are at the festival!

    Matt Damon
    Jason Bateman
    Christian Bale
    L.L. Cool J
    Dave Navarro

  • 53. Steph said:

    1. Johnny Depp
    2. Eammon Sullivan (Aussie swimmer)
    3. Johnny Depp
    4. Val Kilmer
    5. Tom Brady

  • 54. Sarah said:

    1. Billy Joel
    2. Julian Schnabel
    3. Clive Owen
    4. Gerard Butler
    5. Tom Colicchio

  • 55. Mari said:

    1. Leonardo DiCaprio
    2. Jeff Tweedy
    3. Javier Bardem
    4. that guy from Unfaithful (Oliver Martinez?)
    5. Gael Garcia Bernal

  • 56. Searching for the Yeti said:

    1. Edward Norton
    2. Batman (Christian is OK too)
    3. Jack Black
    4. That guy at my gym
    5. My electrician

  • 57. joansy said:

    1. Jack Black (not a physical thing, I think he'd be fun)
    2. Brad Pitt
    3. Angelina Jolie
    4. Ed Norton
    5. Naveen Andrews

  • 58. Lauren said:

    1. Mick Jagger!!! (I've had a crush on him since I was 14)
    2. Robert Downey Jr.
    3. Rupert Grint (Ron from Harry Potter)
    4. Gerard Butler (From P.S. I love you)
    5. Steven Tyler

    Oh and just to mention, the whole Rupert Grint situation. No I am not a pedifile, it's okay I'm only 19!!! :-)

    P.S. LOVE THE SITE!

  • 59. Heidi said:

    1. Daryl Hall
    2. Michael C. Hall
    3. Robert Downy Jr.
    4. John Linnell from TMBG
    5. tie between Bill Maher and Anderson Cooper.

    I had the pleasure of meeting and partying (in the loosest use of the term) Mr. #2, but unfortunately it was before he went on the list.

  • 60. Anonymous said:

    MP has been on my list since 2004...he's now taking up most of the slots on my list too!

  • 61. Adam said:

    Tina Fey and Amy Poeler, but only if they come in a package deal. And only if they talk about how hot I am using that sarcastic lisp they both did so many times on Weekend Update.

  • 62. The Other Dawn said:

    I believe Mr. Phelps had me at what those announcers call his "undulating dolphin swim," AKA that hip-grindy-humpy-thing he does after each turn.

    If lovin' a goofy looking man ten years my junior is wrong, I do NOT want to be right.

  • 63. Amber said:

    1. Damien Rice
    2. Johnny Depp
    3. Daniel Craig
    4. Orlando Bloom
    5. James McAvoy

    Brad Pitt is nowhere near my list, but I'm pretty sure he'd be on my fiance's.

  • 64. Karen said:

    Anytime I try to share my list with my husband, he covers his ears and sings to drown me out. That's communication, baby!

    my list:
    David Duchovny
    Mike Rowe
    David Boreanaz
    Ewan MacGregor
    Sam Rockwell

    My husband's list:
    Gwen Stefani x5

  • 65. Lisa Guidarini said:

    Michael Phelps is a man with some stamina. He can do the breast stroke with me any time. Nudge, nudge, wink, wink.

  • 66. Rob said:

    1. Nicole Kidman
    2. Nastia Liukin
    3. Shirley Manson
    4. Heidi Klum
    5. Rebecca Wolf

  • 67. sarah said:

    DOOCE MEET UP PLEASE! at outside lands? you can tweet where you are and we can tackle i mean say hello???

    see ya at radiohead!! YAY!

  • 68. birdgal said:

    1. Christian Bale
    2. Edward Norton
    3. James McAvoy
    4. Alan Rickman (shutup, it's the voice!)
    5. The entire USA men's swim team (hey, why settle for JUST Michael Phelps? Have you seen Aaron Piersol and Ryan Lochte?!)

  • 69. futura4 said:

    1. MP
    2. George Clooney
    3. Jared Leto
    4. Zach Braff
    5. Gwen Stefani

  • 70. A said:

    - George Clooney
    - Bon Jovi
    - Ryan Gosling
    - Jim Sturgess
    - John Krasinski

  • 71. the dalai mama said:

    Johnny Depp
    Christian Bale
    Jason Stratham
    Brad Pitt
    Brett Favre

  • 72. LA said:

    1. Garth Brooks
    2. Trisha Yearwood
    3. Brad Paisley
    4. Tim McGraw
    5. Faith Hill

  • 73. Heidi said:

    Kyle,
    Have you seen Sin City? If so, how can you pick Elijah?

  • 74. Lisa Guidarini said:

    Oh, damn, forgot this:

    1. Johnny Depp
    2. Rupert Everett
    3. Alan Rickman (THE VOICE)
    4. Johnny Depp
    5. Orlando Bloom

  • 75. PaintingChef said:

    I don't think this is really in order because it changes depending on which one I've seen the most recently...

    Robert Downey Jr.
    Ryan Reynolds
    Jon Hamm
    Tobias Menzies
    George Clooney (who sometimes switches places with Pierce Brosnan depending on whether I've last watched Ocean's 11 or James Bond)

  • 76. et said:

    1. James McAvoy
    2. Jude Law
    3. James Franco
    4. Sting from the 1970's (from Quadrohenia)
    5. Robert Smith (Lead singer of The Cure)circa 1980 before the make-up and extreme weight gain.
    * honorable mention: Edward Norton.

  • 77. Kimi said:

    1. Matt Damon
    2. Matt Damon
    3. Mike Rowe
    4. Harrison Ford
    5. Matt Damon

  • 79. Christine said:

    1.Russel Crowe dressed as 'Gladiator', not Russell Crowe
    from "A Beautiful Mind" ..ewwww
    2. Tony Soprano--Yes, I said it, James Gandolfini.
    3. Christian Bale- Oh Batman, I need to be rescued...
    4. I guess I'd do Brad Pitt, if someone held a gun to
    my head..haha
    5. Vince Vaughn..something about him is so boyishly adorable

  • 80. vicki said:

    1. BonJovi
    2. Patrick Dempsey
    3. Kyle Chandler
    4. Matt LeBlanc
    5. Neil Patrick Harris.....yeah, I know he's gay, but so
    damn hot and I know I could totally turn him straight!!

  • 81. sarah said:

    oh and my list:

    1. zach braff
    2. natalie portman
    3. dave matthews
    4. vinnie (local dj)
    5. tim hudson (pitcher)

  • 82. tupelo said:

    1. Prince
    2. Johnny Depp
    3. David Duchovny
    4. John Corbett
    and finally, my dark secret...
    5. Billy Bob Thornton

  • 83. Steph said:

    1. Ewan McGregor
    2. Ewan McGregor
    3. Ewan Mcgregor
    4. Ewan McGregor
    5. Ewan McGregor

    Do I really think he's all that? Not really, he's cute in that way that British men can be when they've actually received orthodontic care. Still, I like the way my husband gets squirmy when he sees that I like Ewan McGregor enough to list him five times.

  • 84. Chels said:

    Hugh Jackman
    Javier Bardem
    Robert Downey Jr.
    Anderson Cooper
    Ze Frank

  • 85. Mare said:

    1.Ewan McGregor
    2.Jude Law
    3 Ricky Gervais
    4. I'm currently trying to slot Brad Pitt or Orlando Bloom in this slot.
    5. Pending

    I take this list very seriously.

  • 86. Anonymous said:

    Goran Visnjic
    John Cusack
    Hugh Jackman
    Jeff Goldblum
    Stanley Tucci (shut up!)

  • 87. Emma said:

    Seeing as you share my affinity for Chris Martin (seriously, how he looks right now? So Hot.), you might be interested in checking out the interviews that George Stroumboulopoulos recently did with him, as well as Jonny and Guy, for CBC's The Hour (prime-time hip socio-political interview thing that's awesome.) They talk a lot about the new album, run through some of the tracks from previous ones, all in all great interviews. They're available for viewing on the CBC's website (cbc.ca/thehour) or the show has its own page on YouTube.

  • 88. Jen said:

    My husband and I have been keeping our list for years! And, although the rotation has varied over the years, my number one has always been the same.

    Sting
    Rhett Miller (lead singer of Old 97's)
    Djimon Hounsou (of course, I'm reconsidering him since he hooked up with Kimora Lee)
    Matt Damon
    Daniel Craig

    Hubba hubba.

    I have to say that I'm surprised to see John Krasinki on so many lists. It's not that I don't see his appeal (I do! I do!), I'm just surprised to see that he's popped up on so many radars.

  • 89. Amber said:

    Clearly I am a self defeatist. In no particular order:

    Anderson Cooper - Although I fear I'm the wrong gender.
    John Cusack - Brooding melancholy anyone?
    Jon Bon Jovi - I know, how 80's! And he's all of 5 foot 2 but I want to be Gina to his Tommy.
    Taye Diggs - The man is "Drink His Bathwater" hot!
    Kyan Douglas - Of Queer Eye fame. I keep hoping he's a closet hetero?!?!

    My choices in women are too shallow to list publicly....but I will say Megan Fox makes an appearance if that tells you anything.

  • 90. ~Monkey said:

    1) Hugh Jackman (only as Wolverine, not as dandy broadway dude)
    2) Gerard Butler
    3) Benecio Del Toro
    4) Seth Rogan...I dunno either.
    5) Steve Carell

    Listen, I don't get the last two either...it is what it is.

    Also, my two words I have to type to prove I'm not spam are Grant Privates...which is exactly what I'm thinking about. Granting permission to my privates.

  • 91. Amanda said:

    1.- 3. Joaquin Pheonix
    4. Edward Norton
    5. Johnny Depp

    After having dated artists of all sorts, I've liked the actors so far the best (Hi Dave!).

    Also, fantastic Jeff Tweedy clip. Wilco holds a special place for Dave and I, as on our first official date I hopped into his car and, after hearing what was playing on the stereo, said, "Hey, I like Wilco, too." I could tell by his face that I had him then.

  • 92. jo said:

    1. Taye Diggs
    2. Jude Law
    3. Brad Pitt
    4. Johnny Depp
    5. Taye Diggs (yep. He's that hot.)

  • 93. Anonymous said:

    1. Angelina Jolie
    2. John Krasinski
    3. Johnny Depp
    4. Ryan Reynolds
    5. Edward Norton

  • 94. Leslie said:

    How fun. Hmmm...

    1. Tom Brady
    2. David Beckham
    3. George Clooney
    4. Eric Dane
    5. Derek Jeter

  • 95. Sarah said:

    OH MY GOD! Yes for Paul Newman in Cool Hand Luke! Yes a hundred times! & also:

    2. Robert Plant (in the 70's)
    3. Johnny Depp
    4. Ray LaMontagne (his HAIR alone is worthy)
    5. Daniel Day Lewis (in Last of the Mohicans- NOT in Gangs of New York)

    I will say that if my ever so wonderful coconspirator were famous- he would occupy spots 1, 2 & 3. I've often thought of writing to People Magazine and having them do a NOT SO FAMOUS but STILL Sexiest Man of the Year award for him. Johnny Depp would then take the spots 4 &5.

  • 96. Jennifer said:

    Ewan McGregor
    Viggo Mortenson (preferably dressed as Aragorn)
    Brad Pitt
    Harrison Ford
    Willem Defoe (some things can't be explained)

  • 97. Katy said:

    So, I find it incredibly funny that I live less than 30 miles from San Francisco and didn't hear about this music thing. Thanks for planning my weekend for me!

  • 98. marianne said:

    1. Rhett Miller
    2. Jon Brion (perfect example of talent outshining looks)
    3. Ed Norton
    4. James Franco
    5. John Krasinski

  • 99. mjbcoug said:

    No guys posting their lists? What the~?!? Cowards...

    Ashley Judd
    Heather Graham
    Tiffany Thiessen
    Jennifer Love Hewitt
    Keeley Hazell

  • 100. Stellare said:

    The List

    1. Paul Newman
    2. Johnny Depp
    3. Clint Eastwood
    4. Gedeon Burkhard
    5. MacGyver :-) coz he should be real

  • 101. Mia said:

    1. Ryan Gosling 2. Adrian Grenier ( I know, I know, but that documentary he made about finding his father won me over) 3. Matt Damon 4. Johnny Depp 5. Ed Norton

  • 102. Sarah said:

    I forgot to say that (& this is MOST important)-- if I hadn't read the Paul Newman comment... Dave Matthews would be number 1. I love that sneaky smirk... ;)

  • 103. jastereo said:

    1. Minnie Driver
    2. Juliet Binoche
    3. Zooey Deschanel
    4. Rene Russo
    5. Maggie Gyllenhall

  • 104. Christina said:

    1. Dave Matthews (strange I know)
    2. Keifer Sutherland
    3. Matthew Fox
    4. Chris Martin (a new entry since I saw them in concert. Let me just say WOW! is he intense.)
    5. Josh Holloway

    And oh my yes, Michael Phelps. Give me strength with those abs!!

  • 105. Bon Jovi Sandwich said:

    1. Jeffrey Dean Morgan
    2. Bon Jovi
    3. Javier Bardem
    4. Lenny Kravitz
    5. Benjamin Bratt
    5 1/2. I don't swing that way but if I did it'd be Kate the earthquake scientist who comes on the news every time we have an earthquake here in California.

  • 106. Greis (Grace) said:

    This is my first ever comment on DOOCE.com, but I read your blog all the time. I'm pretty addicted...

    My list is as follows:

    1. Justin Timberlake
    2. Josh Turner (he's hot, but he's on my list for his voice alone)
    3. Justin Timberlake
    4. Brad Pitt
    5. Michael Phelps (I wonder if he likes OLDER women? I'm not that much older, only 6 or so years.) :)

  • 107. donna said:

    1. Ralph Fiennes
    2. Harvey Keitel
    3. David Letterman
    4. Chris Martin
    5. Donald Rumsfeld

  • 108. rb said:

    I have had this list for about two years. I has been cleared with hubby:

    George Clooney
    Colin Firth
    Murray Perahia (classical pianist)
    Eric Chavez (3B Oakland As)
    Will Ferrell

    I know there are a lot of random coincidences in the world with seven billion people and all, but I would bet money that no other person on Earth has my exact list.

  • 109. Kara Lang said:

    1. Michael Phelps
    2. David Tennant (I'm a nerd!)
    3. Michael Phelps
    4. Michael Phelps
    5. Jonathan Rhys-Myers

  • 110. Melly said:

    My list doesn't contain Michael. Yet, speaking for Jules, I know Michael (http://bigpikchur.blogspot.com/2008/08/parallel-perpendicular-or-diagona...) joins the likes of:

    1. Antonio Banderas
    2. Jeremy Piven
    3. Javier Bardem
    4. Johnny Depp
    5. Anyone with a thick Latin accent
    6. (secretly) Dara Torres! ha!

  • 111. Cari said:

    Not to mention Michael Phelps gets to eat 10,000 calories a day, which is like, my DREAM.

    My list:

    1. Joaquin Phoenix
    2. Clive Owen
    3. John Stewart
    4. LL Cool J
    5. Keith Olbermann

  • 112. Jess said:

    1. Christian Bale
    2. My work husband...
    3. Clive Owen
    4. Donnie Walhberg (That's right NKOTB!! Seeing him in OCT!)
    5. Michael Phelps

  • 113. Rachel said:

    1. Bono
    2. Jude Law ('90s-era Jude Law, that is)
    3. John Krasinski
    4. Johnny Depp
    5. Anthony Bourdain

    Michael Phelps could make a temporary guest appearance on the list, I guess. The more medals he wins, the better-looking he gets.

  • 114. Samantha said:

    1. Patrick Dempsey
    2. Johnny Depp
    3. Josh Holloway/Naveen Andrews/Matthew Fox (can't choose just one)
    4. James Marsden
    5. Ewan McGregor (with his lovely Scottish accent)

  • 115. Natalie said:

    1. Viggo Mortensen
    2. Adrien Brody
    3. Johnny Depp
    4. Sawyer (from Lost)
    5. Benjamin Brat

  • 116. Leonie said:

    I'm totally with gingela5 - Bear Grylls has to be on the list. The man can survive anywhere and is also rather fit. It doesn't hurt. I have a slight feeling I might have a thing for boyscout men, because I had the biggest crush on MacGyver when I was four. But then I was also in love with Jesus at that stage (Ted Neeley in Jesus Christ Superstar).

    1. Dustin Clare (google please - talk about a smile that turns a girl into a puddle of goo)
    2. Bear Grylls
    2. Hugh Jackman
    4. David Gray (but only if he'll sing for me)
    5. James McAvoy (the man even looks good with goat legs)

  • 117. In the Trenches of Mommyhood said:

    I see where you're coming from on Michael Phelps. However, I will raise you one with Ryan Lochte.

    How about the 2 of them with Adrian Grenier in between? Now THAT's a yummy man-wich!

  • 118. Kara Lang said:

    NO, WAIT! I change my #5 to Viggo Mortensen.
    #6 would be Michael Phelps,
    #7 Christian Bale,
    and THEN, at #8, would be Jonathan Rhys-Myers.

  • 119. Annie said:

    I love Fleet Foxes. I'm from Seattle and still haven't had the chance to see them. I've heard they have a great live show. You'll have to update on how it was!

  • 120. Kristy said:

    In no particular order:
    Andy Garcia
    Zach Braff
    Joaquin Phoenix
    Peter Sarsgaard
    Gordon Ramsay

  • 121. Carrie said:

    In no particular order:

    Clive Owen
    Robby Ginepri
    Hugh Jackman
    Michael Phelps
    Elizabeth Banks

    My boyfriend and I went to a tennis tournament a few weeks ago. All he wanted was to run into Robby G and tell him that he was in my top 5 and to have me back home by morning. True love that man.

  • 122. Samantha said:

    Damn, how did I forget Jeffrey Dean Morgan?

  • 123. katie said:

    1. Mary Louise Parker
    2. Greg Brown's voice
    3. Matt Damon circa Good Will Hunting
    4. John Krasinski
    5. Jamie Oliver, on top of a spread of food he just cooked, while he makes up new clever English slang words for how good I am in bed

  • 124. the OCMD said:

    Michael Phelps is a swimming God! He embodies the ideal male physique. You can't not lust after that. Big ears, underbite and all! He is on my list too. I don't need to look anywhere but down on that man. Others on my list:

    1. Keanu Reeves (ok, he can't act, but so what?)
    2. Toby (the bass player for The Duke Spirit. He sent my little boy a tot sized T-shirt! How can you not fall in love with that?)
    3. Devendra Banhardt (so sexy)
    4. Aaron Eckhardt
    5. Michael Phelps

    I'm counting down the days to Outlands Festival too! Just saw Radiohead at All Points West in NY last weekend and found religion. One of the most beautiful Radiohead shows I've seen yet!

  • 125. The Independent Mom! said:

    Ooooh, I get to post my *list*

    Jared Leto

    Rob Thomas

    Adam Levine

    Matt Hardy

    Jeff Hardy

    what? keep it in the family!

    Last but not least,

    Adam Sandler

  • 126. Acher said:

    In no particular order...

    -Dave Grohl
    -Chris Cornell
    -Scott Wieland (heroin and all)
    -Brad Pitt (Fight Club or A River Runs Through it, though)
    -Bruce Willis. Bald. Definitely bald.

  • 127. Christine said:

    1. Jemaine Clement
    2. Mark Ruffalo
    3. Josh Holloway
    4. Vincent D'Onofrio
    5. Vince Vaughn

  • 128. Shelley said:

    1. matthew mcconaughey--he could just read the phone book to me and i'd be satisfied
    2. jack johnson
    3. ryan reynolds
    4. jonathon rhys myers
    5. will hoge, please if you don't know his music, do yourself a favor

  • 129. Kyran said:

    Teddy Thompson (in a class all by his own fine self)
    Dwight Yoakam (the hat and boots stay on)
    Clive Owen
    Javier Bardem
    and this one's embarrassing, but I sort of have a thing for Joe Biden.

    After Teddy, I suppose I like them a little wild eyed and crazy.

    fun question!

  • 130. Brea said:

    Robert Downey Jr.

    Hugh Jackman

    Benecio del Toro

    George Clooney

    Matt Damon

    I've rediscovered my old crush on Robert Downey Jr. after seeing him on the cover of Rolling Stone.

  • 131. jamie said:

    1. George Clooney
    2. Max Martini - the guy who played Mac on that show 'The Unit'
    3. George Eads -Nick on CSI
    4. Blair Underwood
    5. Daniel Sunjata - have you seen 'Rescue Me'?

    In my younger days, this list would never have been complete without Sammy Hagar! Not sure if I should be proud of that???

  • 132. Sheila said:

    In no particular order:

    George Clooney
    Andy Garcia
    Alberto Tomba, circa 1988 Winter Games (what is it with Olympians?)
    Ralph Fiennes
    Bill Murray (if he stayed in character as the lounge singer on SNL)

  • 133. KC said:

    I forgot Djimon Hounsou.

  • 134. Ben said:

    I only recently learned that Michael Phelps even had a face.

  • 135. The Schumanator said:

    1. Liam Neeson
    2. The guy that always says "Cock sucker!" on Deadwood
    3. Xavier Bardem- (vente para aqui papi)
    4. Ralph Fiennes
    5. Mary Louise Parker. (Not that there's anything wrong with that)

  • 136. Krystal said:

    1. Edward Norton
    2. Henry Rollins
    3. Hugh Jackman
    4. Robert De Niro circa taxi driver
    5. Adrian Brody

    all of these men are between 13 and 43 years older than me and I'm totally okay with that.

    also Jennifer Tilly has her own list where she takes up spots 1-5 for girl crushes. I don't know why but I find her ridiculously attractive.

  • 137. Lyla said:

    1. Jamie Bell
    2. James McAvoy
    3. James Franco
    4. Matt Czurchy
    5. Zach Gilford

  • 138. Michelle Sanders said:

    1. Ray Lamontagne
    2. Matt Damon
    3. Tae Diggs
    4. Matthew Fox
    5. and the one that makes me feel like I'm making a confession... Kevin Costner

  • 139. Amanda said:

    I have 2 lists:

    1) Matthew McConaughey
    2) Ed Norton
    3) Colin Firth
    4) Dave Matthews
    5) Taye Diggs

    1) Idina Menzel (could just combine with # 5 on the male side since they are married, although i'm sure i'm nowhere on either of their lists)
    2) Carrie Underwood
    3) Salma Hayek
    4) Tina Fey
    5) Idina Menzel (great sandwich)

  • 140. sara said:

    I hate to say it, but I think his tattoo placement is a little on the queer side. He might not be that into you ... maybe jon is more his type?

    http://www.popstarsplus.com/images/MichaelPhelpsPicture.jpg

    I don't have much of a list:
    - Jakob Dylan
    - Morris Chestnut
    - Drew Barrymore
    - LL Cool J

    I think that's it.

  • 141. Katherine said:

    After reading previous comments I feel ancient. What IS the mean age of your readership? Michael Phelps was the only one I had even heard of on the lists.

    Everyone on my list has one thing in common ~ long term marriage. I have heard each one publically acknowledge their wives contribution in their life. I find monogomy sexy.

    1. Denzel Washington
    2. Billy Crystal
    3. Will Smith
    4. Alan Alda
    5. Paul Newman

  • 142. k-m-s said:

    Adam Duritz
    Ed Kowalczyk
    Wentworth Miller
    Angeline Jolie
    Olivier Martinez (From Unfaithful with Diane Lane. One. HOT. Movie!)

  • 143. Anonymous said:

    A few years ago a male friend and I had a discussion about the ugliest celebrities we would sleep with. Mine was Jack Black and my 21 year old male friends choice was... Liza Minelli. I still can't get over it.

    As for my list:
    1. Ryan Gosling
    2. Josh Jackson
    3. Wes Bentley (from 'American Beauty')
    4. Edward Norton
    5. Chris Martin

  • 144. Bri said:

    1. Vince Vaughn
    2. Jack Johnson
    3. Josh Lucas (only in Sweet Home Alabama)
    4. Matthew Fox
    5. Aaron Piersol (sorry, he is way hotter than Phelps)

    My husband's all time number one is Queen Latifah!

  • 145. Is it hot in here said:

    In no particular order.

    ~ Harvey Keitel (from The Piano) admittedly, I haven't quite figured it out either?

    ~ Kevin Costner (before he cheated on his wife on their honeymoon)

    ~ John Krasinski

    ~ John Corbett

    ~ Call me shallow, but I'd do Michael Phelps from the neck down- as long as he didn't talk about "W". THAT would be a deal breaker!

  • 146. The Independent Mom! said:

    How could I forget

    DREW BARRYMORE

    My hubby and I fight over her, guess we'll have to share her, lol

    As far as women go, well, I have a list in that realm too, LOL

  • 147. Brandi Koskie said:

    1. Johnny Depp
    2. Dave Matthews
    3. Matthew McConaughey
    4. Adam Duritz
    5. Justin Timberlake

    Honorable Mentions...
    Anderson Cooper
    Michael Phelps
    Denzel Washington

  • 148. Mo said:

    Jack Johnson
    Michael Owen
    Josh Turner
    Christian Bale
    George Clooney

  • 149. Katie said:

    Here goes:

    1. John Krasinski
    2. Jake Gyllenhaal
    3. Ryan Gosling
    4. John Cusack
    5. James Marsden

    I also have a running list in my head of female celebrities who I think are so darn beautiful, I might think about maybe someday making out with a woman for:

    1. Katherine Heigl
    2. Scarlett Johansson
    3. Jennifer Anniston
    4. Maggie Gyllenhaal
    5. Kate Hudson

  • 150. Lisa said:

    My Husbands list and my list really read like this:

    1. Anyone famous
    2. Anyone famous
    3. Anyone famous
    4. Anyone famous
    5. Anyone famous

    If either one of us run into ANYONE we could brag about fucking, we've both given the go-ahead. Who am I to deny my Husband Jennifer Garner even if he doesn't like her enough to put on his list, but she's ready, willing and able?

    And maybe John Stamos isn't in my top five, but I surely wouldn't kick him out of my bed if he invited himself into it... Besides... I hear he's not half bad...

  • 151. Kathy said:

    Paul Newman used to be the only one on my list. I'm ignoring the whole aging thing, since this isn't really based in reality anyway. So, here goes, in no particular order...
    1. Dave Grohl
    2. Daniel Craig
    3. Paul Newman
    4. Clive Owen
    5. Michael Phelps

    Kate Hudson was on my husband's list, then we actually saw her at a museum opening (with Lance, of course). So sad for him that that is as close as he will get!

  • 152. zanie said:

    1. Pierce Brosnan
    2. Michael Phelps
    3. Karch Kiraly
    4. Laird Hamilton
    5. Sean Connery - James Bond era

  • 153. Stacy said:

    Ewan MacGregor is Scottish, and he is very hot, especially since he had that big ol mole hacked off his forehead.

    George Clooney

    Harrison Ford, back in the Star Wars days

    Clive Owen

    used to have Brad Pitt on the list, but he creeps me out now; too bad since the dedicated dad thing is very hot

  • 154. Rachel said:

    John Doe
    Mark Lanegan
    Greg Dulli
    Nick Cave
    Mike Ness

  • 155. Jill Mormon said:

    I shouldn't have looked at that band list. I kind of hate you now. *sigh*

    1. Angelina Jolie
    2. Christian Bale
    3. Clive Owen
    4. William Petersen - Yes, Grissom from CSI. I should be embarrassed, I think, but strangely I am not.
    5. Ryan Phillipe

  • 156. la_florecita said:

    1. Jon Stewart
    2. Saul Williams
    3. Anthony Bourdain
    4. Shakira

    I'm leaving it at those 4. There are a ton of other people I think are hot, but can't vouch for their whole package.

  • 157. Vanessa said:

    So glad we aren't the only relationship continuing the "Marital Exclusions" policy.

    We are each allowed only one exclusion at a time, however, we can change the one exclusion (may take up to 24 hours to take effect, however - you can't see someone hot walking by and say "excuse me, THAT is my marital exclusion, see you later.")

    My current exclusion has, and will continue to be, Eddie Vedder - with my husband's full and unconditional support.

  • 158. Sherry said:

    In no particular order:

    1. David Cook (I know)
    2. Blake Lewis (clearly I have a thing for American Idol contestants)
    3. Antonio Banderas
    4. Alan Rickman dressed as Snape
    5. Angelina Jolie

  • 159. Hannah said:

    Oooh!

    1. Michael Phelps
    2. Alan Rickman
    3. Michael Phelps
    4. Michael Phelps
    5. Natalie Couglin (hey, I'm an equal opportunity swimfan)

    My husband, when he found out that you could keep such a list said:

    1. Those bendy women from the Athleta catalog (srsly - that one! Her leg is behind her head!)
    2. Those super cool athletic women from the Title 9 catalog (they could totally take you down with, like, their pinky)

    You can tell what's in the pile in our bathroom...

  • 160. Jasi said:

    Mine
    1. Jake Gyllenhaal
    2. Elijah Wood
    3. Michael Rosenbaum
    4. Angelina Jolie
    5. Rachel Weiss

    DH's
    1,2,5. Milla Jovovich
    3,4. Jennifer Connley

  • 161. Nicole said:

    Ha...I too have fallen, or sunk, hard for Phelps.

    My list:

    1. Willaim Peterson - CSI Las Vegas
    2. Josh Gates - Destination Truth
    3. Michael Phelps
    4. Richard Gere - the Pretty Woman years
    5. David Duchovny - X-Files

  • 162. Brea said:

    I saw #127's list and had to make a revision.

    I am bumping Hugh Jackman, in favor of Mark Ruffalo. He and Meg Ryan starred in the soft-core porn movie In The Cut.

    *fans self*

  • 163. Emily d. said:

    I will look forward to seeing you (and the 40k other people) at outside lands this weekend! It should be fun.

    My list is as follows:

    - Brad Pitt
    - Noah Lowry (pitcher for the SF giants)
    - Colin Firth
    - Michael Cera when he is 10 years older
    - One of the owners at Sebo sushi in San Francisco (Paul Rudd but hotter)

  • 164. Honey said:

    Any 5 of the Marley brothers, except Lauryn Hill's man; she's tough.

    Which brings me to the reason I came to post:

    Do not miss K'Naan on Sunday!
    I saw him on tour with Damian and Stephen Marley and was blown away. He grew up in East African and fires the truth right at you. "Never let 'em see you down--smile while you're bleedin'!"

  • 165. misstraceynolan said:

    My list is always in flux. It currently looks something like this (in no particular order):

    Denzel
    Clooney
    Charlie Rose
    Robert Downey Jr
    Obama

    I'm seriously considering opening up a spot for Aaron Sorkin. Or Clive Owen. Maybe Clooney's spot. He can get bumped to my Fantasy Dinner Party list with Anderson Cooper, Spike Lee and that Phelps kid.

  • 166. Kristen from Ma said:

    Chris Martin? He who enabled Paltrow to reproduce? Bleh!

    Daniel Day-Lewis
    Ewan MacGregor
    Pierce Brosnan
    George Clooney
    Bono

    Yes, I like the Celts.

  • 167. Sara said:

    I hate being limited to 5 :) The top 4 are givens on my list, but #5 is a toss up

    Adrian Grenier
    Matt Damon
    George Clooney
    Taye Diggs
    Justin Timberlake/Daniel Craig/Christian Bale.

    If you only get 5 people on your list, why waste a spot with re-listing people? My husband knows that I'd leave him for any of my top 4! :)

  • 168. Rachel said:

    I'm cracking up because as I read through the first couple dozen lists I realized your internet readers are all so similar. Not a big suprise but funny. :-)

    That being said:

    1. Ewen McGreggor
    2. Ed Norton
    3. Christian Bale
    4. Milo Ventimiglieahgilly (How do you spell his name?)
    5. I would agree with Phelps, but I read he is a W fan. Gross.

  • 169. Ana C said:

    1. My husband
    2. My husband
    3. My husband
    4. My husband
    5. My husband

    your list may change too if you met the guy ;)

  • 170. Ana C said:

    1. My husband
    2. My husband
    3. My husband
    4. My husband
    5. My husband

    your list may change too if you met the guy ;)

  • 171. Holly said:

    1. Ryan Reynolds
    2. Brad Pitt (circa FIGHT CLUB or MR. & MRS. SMITH)
    3. Vince Vaughn
    4. Adam Levine
    5. Angelina Jolie

  • 172. Emily said:

    I totally think Michael Phelps is a hottie, too, and my friends make fun of me because they say he looks like he's got Downs Syndrome. I say no way and the ears are sexy! :)

    My list:

    1. George Clooney
    2. George Clooney
    3. George Clooney
    4. George Clooney
    5. Brad Pitt

  • 173. Brandi Koskie said:

    Decided to make a list of hot girl crushes too....

    1. Tina Fey
    2. Katie Holmes
    3. January Jones (Mad Men)
    4. Julia Roberts
    5. Maggie Gylenhaal

  • 174. Marianne said:

    John Krasinski
    Jeffrey Dean Morgan
    David Boreanaz
    Rodney Atkins
    And I would switch teams for Sara Ramirez.

    Michael Phelps is absolutely drool-inducing, but something's keeping him off my list. Possibly my jealousy at his 12000calorie-a-day requirements.

  • 175. Darci said:

    1. George Clooney
    2. Michael Phelps - but only if I can change his politics
    3. Denzel Washington
    4. Will Smith
    5. John Corbet

  • 176. amberg said:

    1. will smith
    2. clive owen
    3. jude law
    4. bustah rhymes
    5. jason mraz

  • 177. Lisa (Strong Rhetoric) said:

    Do fictional men count? If so...

    1. Fitzwilliam Darcy as himself
    2. Colin Firth as Fitzwilliam Darcy
    3. James McAvoy as Tom Lefroy
    4. John Cusack as Lloyd Dobler
    5. John Hamm as Don Draper

    More on my list at http://strongrhetoric.blogspot.com/2008/03/by-jove-ive-got-it.html.

  • 178. jennifer said:

    - Javier Bardem
    - Robert Downy jr
    - Steven Colbert
    - Andy Garcia
    - Luke Wilson

  • 179. The Diva on a Diet said:

    1. Lenny Kravitz
    2. Mick Jagger (way old, I know, but I mean the 1970's Mick)
    3. Johnny Damon (Yankee Damon, not Cro-magnon Damon)
    4. George Clooney
    5. Vince Vaughn

    Fairly generic, but there you are.

  • 180. Amber said:

    Michael Phelps has recently been added to my list as well, and the ears and the underbite just enhance his charm for me!

    1. Clive Owen
    2. Robert Downey, Jr. (lord help me, even with the checkered past, he is a sexy, sexy man)
    3. Michael Phelps
    4. Anthony Bourdain
    5. Josh Holloway (Sawyer on Lost, so dirty hot)

  • 181. Megan said:

    1. ryan gosling
    2. ryan reynolds
    3. christian bale
    4. michael phelps
    5. brad pitt

    p.s. when you go to san fran, check out sharon jones and the dap kings on sunday. that music will make your limbs/body gyrate uncontrollably.

  • 182. Blythe said:

    1/Sean Bean
    2/Karl Urban
    3/Christian Bale
    4/Jake Gyllenhaal
    5/John Cusack

    ULTIMATE LIST!!!

  • 183. Carrie said:

    Only five? This is going to be hard.

    1. Tori Amos
    1. Clive Owen
    3. Brangelina (sandwich)
    4. Michael Phelps
    5. Karina Lombard

    One of the words to test whether or not I'm a human visitor is "lay".

    And for the Ryan Lochte fans out there: http://jezebel.com/5036655/the-world-of-ryan-lochte-is-one-of-diamond-gr...

  • 184. DoodleB said:

    Oh, this is fun. While watching "The Dark Knight" yesterday I told my husband about my new #1.

    1) Christian Bale, he makes me feel funny down there
    2) John Krasinski, I want to be Pam
    3) Joshua Morrow, my boyfriend of 14 years, Nick on Y&R
    4) John Cusack, young John looks like my husband, so cute!
    5) Matt Damon, love the sensitive action hero

    Now I just need my John Cusack looking husband to get home so I can jump him.

  • 185. draagonfly said:

    1. Jason Mraz (definitely The Whole Package)
    2. Jason Mraz
    3. Ashton Kutcher (call me Demi)
    4. Jeffrey Dean Morgan (Google a pic and you'll go "Oh!")
    5. Paul Rudd (Another Google and you'll remember)

    Those boys on the Abercrombie web site are really something to look at too, but I dunno if you could get them away from a mirror long enough to do any good.

    When I was six, I was convinced I would marry the Disney animation of Robin Hood. I'm still thinking about it since my pets have been more reliable than my men.

  • 186. Sheshie said:

    1. Brandon Flowers
    2. Clive Owen
    3. Matt Bellamy
    4. Enrique Merciano
    5. Josh Duhamel

  • 187. Nhiro said:

    I'm gonna be in SF this weekend! I heard about the festival a while back, but we're trying to sight-see (never been to NorCal) so I don't think I'll have time or $$ to attend. Poo.

    The only two I have on my list so far are Johnny Depp and Channing Tatum.

    I see Hugh Jackman's on a lot of these lists. So incredibly rugged. YUM.

  • 188. jannie said:

    Bruce Springsteen
    George Clooney
    Jon Stewart
    Steven Colbert
    Mos Def

  • 189. Carrie said:

    In my list above, Gerard Butler was knocked out by Michael Phelps.

  • 190. Jill said:

    Oh, that Michael Phelps...all I have to say is that I don't much notice his teeth and ears. If you know what I mean... ;)

  • 191. Anonymous said:

    Sara 140.

    Queer side, you say? That picture just makes me want to peel those U.S. of A Speedos off and explore his Olympic rings a little further.

    http://www.popstarsplus.com/images/MichaelPhelpsPicture.jpg

  • 192. Jennifer lundgren said:

    1. Stephen Colbert
    2. Gary Sinese
    3. George Clooney
    4. Matt Lauer
    5. the responsible brother from "Wings"... Tim something?

    Now I have to go be myself for a bit....

  • 193. Natalie said:

    1. Alan Rickman
    2. Alan Rickman
    3. Alan Rickman
    4. Alan Rickman
    5. Severus Snape

    (I know the last one is a fictional character, but given that he's played by actors 1-4, I think that greatly improves my chances, yes?)

  • 194. kate said:

    1. Ira Glass (don't tell me I need to explain this one)
    2. Eddie Vedder
    2. George Clooney
    3. Jon Stewart
    5. John Cusak

  • 195. Jess said:

    I love this game!

    Right now my list is pretty fluid, but #1 and #2 are always the same:

    1. Jonathan Rhys Meyers
    2. Cillian Murphy
    3. Javier Bardem
    4. Apollo Uno (I usually don't go for chin scruff so this one's a little unual for me)
    5. Timothy Olyphant

  • 196. BOSSY said:

    It's the constant mention of Michael's chronic Attention Deficit Disorder that worries Bossy more than the ears or the teeth. Or maybe that's just Mrs. Phelps ways of routing out bad potential daughter-in-laws.

  • 197. Kelly said:

    1. Ben Folds
    2. Steve Carell
    3. John Stewart
    4. Clive Owen
    5. Jack White

    All Michael Phelps needs is a bag for his head. Everything else would be juuuust fine.

  • 198. rhea said:

    In no particular order:
    Benicio del Toro
    Gerard Butler
    Ryan Gosling
    James MacAvoy
    Jonathan Rhys-Myers

    Wouldn't kick 'em outta bed:
    John Krasinski
    Vincent D'Onofrio
    George Clooney
    Ryan Reynolds

    Of course, all the smokers would have to quit, but you know...

  • 199. Cristina said:

    Hmmm...This week the lineup looks like this:

    Clive Owen
    Anthony Bourdain
    George Clooney
    Matt Berninger (after seeing the National last week)
    Hunter Parrish (anyone watching Weeds? I know he's young, but ooooooohhhh, baby!)

  • 200. Bridge said:

    1. Christian Bale
    2. Christian Bale
    3. Tiger Woods
    4. Ashton Kutcher
    5. Rob Lowe

  • 201. Jewels said:

    1. Jason Statham
    2. Matt Damon
    3. Mark Paul Gosselaar[....yeah...i know.]
    4. Brad Pitt
    5. Adam van Koeverden [Canadian Olympic Kayaker]

  • 202. Wonton said:

    1. Trent Reznor Yum
    2. Gael Garcia Bernal Double yum!!
    3. Billy Zane
    4. Jon Stewart
    5. Neil Gaiman

    My list differs a bit from yours in that I would like to keep these people in a cage in my garage. Is that bad? LOL!

  • 203. Liz said:

    Ew, the only way I would touch Michael Phelps is if there was a paper bag over his head.

    But here is my list you can be grossed out by!
    1. James McAvoy
    2. Christian Bale
    3. Mark Ronson
    4. Ewan McGregor
    5. Adrien Brody

  • 204. Ellen said:

    1. Jessica Alba
    2. Jake Gyllenhaal
    3. Enrique Iglesias
    4. Audrey Tautou
    5. Rufus Wainwright

  • 205. emilyi said:

    This is hard to narrow to just 5 but here goes:

    1. John Krasinski- i'm a huge Office fan and yes i have seen the UK version
    2. James McAvoy- That sex scene in Atonement was HOT
    3. Colin Firth- I love him in all movies i see him in
    4. Matt Damon- Didn't have him on the list until the Bourne series and then it was like... whoa
    5. Daniel Craig- James Bond enough said

    Famous people i've actually had dreams about (that I remember)

    John Krasinski
    Johnny Depp

  • 206. houndrat said:

    Wow, I don't know---Michael Phelps is such a young pup. I remember when I was like 13 and swimming I had a crush on Rowdy Gains, who is actually the Olympic swimming announcer now. Okay, so now I really feel old. At any rate, I think I even have a photo of the two of us somewhere, back from when I used to stalk him at our local pool.....

    But Brad Pitt is a keeper.

    I'm seriously jealous of the music fest. It sounds very Coachella-esque. Ah, the good old pre-kid days...kudos to you for going post-kid.

  • 207. Nothing But Bonfires said:

    1. Jordan Catalano
    2. Jordan Catalano
    3. Jordan Catalano
    4. Jordan Catalano
    5. Jordan Catalano

  • 208. Bertha said:

    We saw Fleet Foxes in Boston last month and they were incredible! It's sure to be a great show! They are definitely my favorite new band, possibly surpassing Band of Horses which was my previous favorite new band, even though they aren't that new anymore.

    Also:

    -Chris Martin (back off, he's mine)
    -John Krasinski
    -Bono (shut up)
    -Jason Bateman
    -Kiefer Sutherland

  • 209. Adrienne said:

    1. Hugh Laurie
    2. Ed Kowalczyk (lead singer of the band Live)
    3. Andy Garcia
    4. Matthew Macfadyen
    5. Eric Bana

  • 210. Rochelle said:

    OMG I'll be in SF this weekend. maybe I'll look for you at the show.

  • 211. Sarah said:

    This took me a really long time, and I've decided that the fifth position will be rotating:

    1. John Krasinski
    2. Craig Krenzel
    3. Christian Bale
    4. George Clooney
    5. Matt Grevers

  • 212. Laura said:

    1. Jon Stewart
    2. Harry Connick Jr.
    3. Ed Robertson (Barenaked Ladies)
    4. Tony Hawk
    4. Matthew Perry (Because he IS just like Chandler Bing)

    hmmmmm... yep, I lean towards the dork side!

    Phelps is growing on me, and may join my guilty pleasure list... of the youngin's..

    Shia Lebeouf, Phil of the Future..(sorry never bothered to look up his name), Justin Timberlake...

  • 213. Joanne said:

    1. Jason Statham
    2. Matt Damon
    3. Wentworth Miller
    4. David Cook
    5. Erick Lindgren (poker player)

  • 214. Jenny said:

    David Duchovny
    Dave Matthews
    Ewan McGregor
    Robert Downy Jr.
    Did I mention David Duchovny?

    I am SO addicted to Californication. Anyone else watch it?

  • 215. Tasha said:

    I didn't have an official list before. But these comments have definitely inspired me.

    Jason Statham
    Daniel Craig
    Clive Owen (I like them Brits)
    Sawyer from Lost
    Brad Pitt from Fight Club (I also like them dirty)

    I don't need them in any particular order. Just one at a time so I can savor, please.

  • 216. LizandBoys said:

    STING...he's always been my number 1
    Harrison Ford
    Taye Diggs
    Johnny Depp
    Cal Ripken, Jr. (retired Baltimore Orioles Catcher...not only does he have DREAMY BLUE eyes, but he's a great guy)

    I still dream of the day Sting knocks on my door and takes me away...my husband knows I'm waiting.

  • 217. cevec said:

    Dave Matthews
    James Gandolfini
    Philip Seymour Hoffman
    Johnny Depp
    Michael Phelps