Masthead Menu

  • About this site
  • Contact Me
  • Archives
  • Mastheads
  • Shop
  • FAQ
  • community
  • view
  • view
  • view
dooce® - dooce.com

The labor story, part one

I have sat down to write this post so many times and abandoned the effort because I didn't know if I was going to be able to summon the words to describe what a sacred and spiritual experience labor was for me this time around. Yes. Sacred and spiritual. Words you never thought you'd hear from someone who can talk about breakfast cereal and hemorrhoids in the same sentence with the hemorrhoids being the part that didn't make you throw up.

Up until about the 30th week of my pregnancy I hadn't given labor much thought, only that I was going to ask for the epidural two days before contractions started. I'm not kidding, that was the extent of my birth plan. There was no need to experience any of the pain, I thought, especially since I had been through this before and I remember thinking that the pain was so awful that it was going to kill me. Give me the epidural and any other pain relief, maybe throw in a couple dozen shots of bourbon, oh and how about you just put me under general anesthesia and wake me up two days later. I'm not good with pain. I tend to complain and holler and call people regrettable things. It's like the Hulk, only he's on his period.

I was also under the impression, having never really researched the subject whatsoever, that any woman who would opt for a homebirth was not only COMPLETELY OUT OF HER MIND but also not interested in the safety of her unborn child. I mean, there's a reason that infant and maternal mortality rates are so much better than a hundred years ago, right? HOSPITALS. And MEDICINE. And smart people we call DOCTORS. Yes, women routinely used to go out into the field by themselves and give birth without any assistance, and many of them routinely did not return BECAUSE THEY DIED.

But then out of no where the publishers of Ricki Lake and Abby Epstein's book Your Best Birth sent me a copy, just like the publishers of many books send me copies of other books all the time. Internet, I have rooms full of books that publishers have sent me. ROOMS FULL. And I was just about to toss this onto the mountainous pile of ones I'd eventually drop off at Goodwill when, I don't know, I flipped through a few pages and gave a full minute to one or two paragraphs. And those two paragraphs happened to be ones that really pissed me off. So much so that I read them aloud to Jon and said something like GOD, THOSE HIPPIES! or I BET THEY SMELL LIKE PATCHOULI!

You know, something totally open-minded.

Those paragraphs pissed me off so badly, in fact, that the one part of me that resembles my father the most — no, not the pointy chin or the metabolism or the absolute inability to watch a movie where everything goes wrong and the protagonist just keeps getting pummeled by life and I'm all MAKE IT STOP and then I have get up and actually leave the theater, no, none of those things — my righteous indignation, it flared up so magnificently that I sat down to read the whole book, just so that I could be angry at it. WHO DOES SHIT LIKE THIS? Me and Michael Hamilton, that's who. Both he and I will go to our graves filled with an inordinate amount of unproductive anger, but a smile will mark our faces because we will feel so justified. So RIGHT.

And then, oh God, the worst thing happened. And I didn't even see it coming, but I'm sitting there reading that book, gritting my teeth, shaking my head when all of a sudden it started to make sense. I started to see just how medicalized labor and birth have become in America AND THERE GOES MY WORLD VIEW.

I'm not going to get into the specifics and the really convincing and at times jaw-dropping statistics of it here, there are so many other places and people who can write about it better than I can, but I will say this: if you are pregnant or are planning to become pregnant, GO READ THAT BOOK. From now on when someone asks me what is the one piece of advice I would give to a pregnant woman, it will be: GO BUY A COPY OF THAT BOOK. Listen, I am not affiliated with that book in any way, I do not know Ricki Lake, she and I do not vacation in St. Tropez together (although if she'd like to come ride four-wheelers at my Mom's cabin in Duchesne, Utah, THE OFFER STANDS), I do not owe that publisher any favors. But IT CHANGED MY LIFE. I'm not even kidding, I'll say it again: IT CHANGED MY LIFE.

So then I watched the documentary Ricki Lake made, The Business of Being Born and that sealed it for me, I got my hands on everything I could read about natural childbirth. I read websites, forums, several other books including the excellent Birthing from Within, and then I talked to everyone I could find who had experienced birth without drugs. It just made a lot of sense to me, and after working through the specifics of what I went through when I was in labor with Leta — what I would call a classic example of a medicalized American labor and delivery minus the c-section — I decided that I wanted to have a natural childbirth this time. A very personal decision that made Jon go, HUH?????

And then he choked on those questions marks and fell over.

First, there were several obstacles to overcome. One, I had to convince Jon that I wasn't crazy. I had done so much reading and research that I had gone from thinking homebirthing was NUTSO to wanting to push the baby out in the tiny tub we have in the bathroom next to the garage with no one in the room but Jon and a midwife. Oooh, and lots of candles!

But I knew Jon would never be okay with a homebirth, and since I was going to need his help getting through the pain of a drug-free labor even in a hospital setting, having him on board was critical. Two, what was my OBGYN going to do when suddenly the woman who was all EPIDURAL ON THE ROCKS, PLEASE! suddenly starting asking about the c-section rate at the hospital, and what was her policy on episiotomies? And this? And that? And, what do you know, she started fidgeting nervously, biting her lower lip, subtly shaking her head, and that was the quickest check-up I'd had the whole pregnancy!

Now, I really like my OBGYN. She's the complete opposite of me, very cheery and all smiles, and I bet she was popular in high school, as in, when she thinks back on those four years she doesn't SHIT HER PANTS like I do. And instead of writing her off as someone who would purposefully stand in the way of a natural childbirth and seeking out another doctor or midwife at such a late date, I decided to give her the benefit of the doubt.

And I'm glad I did, because she did nothing but encourage my plans throughout the subsequent check-ups.

And hoo-boy, there was planning. Because if I was remembering correctly there was a point in my labor with Leta when the pain had become so unbearable that I think I may have actually died, gone to Hell, and when Satan saw that it was me he was all, no, no, no, not that woman, I am not about to spend eternity with someone so crass that they would casually talk about duck farts while I'm eating small children for breakfast. Send her back!

I was going to need to prepare myself for the pain, mentally, physically, and emotionally, and surround myself with a team of people who could help me through it. So I hired a doula, and then I gathered the people who were going to be with me during labor and we worked through what I wanted and how to make that happen. Mind you, I went into this knowing fully that what I wanted to happen could be completely derailed by any sort of crisis concerning me or the baby. Making it out alive with a healthy baby was my top priority, of course, but if there was no need for pitocin or an epidural or intravenous drugs or a vacuum or forceps or an oxygen mask or an emergency c-section, then that's what I wanted.

And really, that's not a lot to ask.

....

Jon just walked in with Marlo and my milk came in so hard that it exploded all over the keyboard. Imagery! And I just realized how long this post is already, and I haven't even gotten to the part where I asked our server at Outback Steakhouse if she'd be willing to cut the umbilical cord. Part two coming soon!

07.13.2009 Daily, Pregnancy 819 comments
Previous Post Next Post
  • 1. megan said:

    OMG, am I first?? Ok, I'll go read now. Finally!! :-D

    07.13.09 - 02:48 PM
  • 2. adrienne said:

    giving birth is a remarkable feat on it's own, but to do it naturally is bigger than big. congratulations, you have everything to be proud of.

    07.13.09 - 02:51 PM
  • 3. Megan said:

    Wow! This is completely unexpected. I'm looking forward to hearing the story!

    07.13.09 - 02:52 PM
  • 4. jennifer said:

    I'm so excited to hear about the rest of your labor and Marlo's birth. I had a natural birth too, and found it so empowering. Kind of crazy, but empowering. I think my husband might be scarred for life because of all the sounding I did, but it was an amazing experience. Cheers to you!

    07.13.09 - 02:53 PM
  • 5. christine said:

    Really looking fwd to the rest of this story - I know it'll be good!

    07.13.09 - 02:54 PM
  • 6. Rachel Shepard said:

    Thank you, Dooce. From an official homebirth nutso - Thank you.

    07.13.09 - 02:54 PM
  • 7. JIll Put Up A Blog said:

    Seriously, I am like when I have a baby - "Give me the drugs" - I stink with pain, but what a remarkable story and inspiring. I am sure to, this being your second was less - unknown. Looking for part II:)

    07.13.09 - 02:54 PM
  • 8. melissa said:

    Oh how I've been waiting for this story!

    07.13.09 - 02:55 PM
  • 9. Elisabeth said:

    That documentary was AMAZING so I can only imagine how great the book is! Can't wait to hear the rest of the story!

    07.13.09 - 02:55 PM
  • 10. Dawn said:

    Tuck your boob back in and finish the story!!! I can't wait to hear more!!!!

    07.13.09 - 02:55 PM
  • 11. JIll Put Up A Blog said:

    Seriously, I am like when I have a baby - "Give me the drugs" - I stink with pain, but what a remarkable story and inspiring. I am sure too, this being your second was less - unknown. Looking forward to part II:)

    07.13.09 - 02:56 PM
  • 12. Hokie Deb said:

    -->They turned off the drugs for me after 40+ hours in labor.
    My husband being sensitive brought in hot wings from Hooters and stuff to make gin and tonics to the hospital.
    I don't like gin and tonics. Ha!

    Marlo is as beauty.

    07.13.09 - 02:56 PM
  • 13. Ashly said:

    AWESOME!! I've been waiting for this. I can't wait to read part II.

    07.13.09 - 02:56 PM
  • 14. adventurekait said:

    I was really looking forward to this story, and by golly it's living up to my expectations. And also making my uterus hurt for baby. Thanks for that.

    07.13.09 - 02:56 PM
  • 15. Milla said:

    ...sewing up the lady parts...

    07.13.09 - 02:57 PM
  • 16. Noelle said:

    wow..as always..wow

    07.13.09 - 02:57 PM
  • 17. hoskas said:

    I still get my share of the drugs though right, to take at my leisure? To help me get through those long nights of nipple burning loneliness.

    07.13.09 - 02:58 PM
  • 18. Whitney said:

    While I'm not planning on having children anytime soon, watching The Business of Being Born definitely made me rethink my views on natural birth. I can't say for sure if I'd have one, but it was one of the most eye-opening documentaries I have ever seen. I'm looking forward to reading part two!

    07.13.09 - 02:58 PM
  • 19. holly said:

    I just found out I am pregnant. I had seen The Business of Being Born back in January and my husband and I were totally on board with home birth right then. We are in San Francisco and there is an incredible network of midwives and homebirth options here! Since our big news, I started thinking of my own labor and upon reflection I could sense that my will had flagged a bit, and I was seriously considering a hospital birth again. (but with the Midwife and a birthplan.) But after reading this I am back on board. Heading to Amazon.com to order those books right after I hit the send key here.

    Can't wait to hear the rest... thanks!

    07.13.09 - 02:58 PM
  • 20. Janette said:

    I am waiting for the day when they find a happy medium between delivering at home with a midwife and delivering in a hospital numb from the chest down. I like the idea of a minimal-intervention birth, but I I don't like the pain. I couldn't handle it even if my life depended on it. I do want midwives to be able to administer epidurals while I lay in my bed at home. That would be awesome.
    I look forward to hearing the rest of the story. Congrats on the natural birth.

    07.13.09 - 02:58 PM
  • 21. spelhouseLove said:

    Thank you for sharing :)

    07.13.09 - 02:59 PM
  • 22. Tara@Sticky Fingers said:

    How did the whole labour (I'm British. I spell it correctly!) thing change so much since I had my girl just 3 short years ago?
    I would have loved to have gone down the doula/hypnobirthing route and am so pleased that it is becoming so much more 'accepted' and more and more women are looking into that option rather than the hospital's usual 'lie down here love in this unnatural, uncomfortable postion and do exactly as I say rather than what your body is telling you'.

    07.13.09 - 03:00 PM
  • 23. Lisa said:

    I haven't had a baby and am totally terrified of going through childbirth.. I am very interested in how you did this!

    07.13.09 - 03:00 PM
  • 24. No. 17 Cherry Tree Lane said:

    I'm really looking forward to hearing about your labor story. I was told (even before I went into labor) that my child was going to be HUGE and would need to be taken out via C-section. It was the "only option".

    She was only 8 pounds.

    I have felt robbed (cant think of a better word) since then and always a little disappointed. Yes....disappointed that I wasn't able to feel the horrendous pain.

    Since I had her, I have watched that documentary and am now going to buy the book you recommended.

    Thanks Dooce,
    Rachel

    07.13.09 - 03:02 PM
  • 25. No. 17 Cherry Tree Lane said:

    I'm really looking forward to hearing about your labor story. I was told (even before I went into labor) that my child was going to be HUGE and would need to be taken out via C-section. It was the "only option".

    She was only 8 pounds.

    I have felt robbed (cant think of a better word) since then and always a little disappointed. Yes....disappointed that I wasn't able to feel the horrendous pain.

    Since I had her, I have watched that documentary and am now going to buy the book you recommended.

    Thanks Dooce,
    Rachel

    07.13.09 - 03:02 PM
  • 26. Jessie said:

    Yay for natural childbirth! I'm glad the experience was so wonderful for you.

    07.13.09 - 03:02 PM
  • 27. Britt said:

    Although my 2nd child's birth was NOT planned to be "natural" it ended up that way and I was so glad it did. First, that I survived the pain and second, the bonding and recovery were so much better it was all worth it. I am really excited for you. You can do ANYTHING!

    07.13.09 - 03:03 PM
  • 28. Nicole said:

    You're a rock star. Can't wait to hear the rest of the story.

    Me and my 5 month pregnant self are headed to the bookstore to pick up a copy of the book you mentioned.

    07.13.09 - 03:03 PM
  • 29. blakspring said:

    I love the idea of a natural birth but I'm sure I'd chicken out when push came to shove. You are a brave woman Heather. Can't wait to read Part Two

    07.13.09 - 03:03 PM
  • 30. Allyn said:

    I can't wait to hear the rest. I'm trying to get pregnant, and watched the documentary and was amazed by all the info in it (including my old ob/gyn!). I'll definitely check out the book once we get some action over here!

    07.13.09 - 03:04 PM
  • 31. The Blushing Hostess said:

    It needs to be the way your heart guides you. I was all hospital and pain killers, but you need to bring that baby in with your best mental foot forward and I am glad you found your path, assuming this was it...

    07.13.09 - 03:04 PM
  • 32. Laurel said:

    Um, Heather? I sent you my book because I thought you might enjoy it. I don't even have a publisher. Please don't take it to Goodwill. :)

    07.13.09 - 03:05 PM
  • 33. Devon said:

    I totally respect your decision, and although the pain sounds, um, HORRIFYING, I hope that I am as brave as you are when it's my turn to make those decisions.

    07.13.09 - 03:06 PM
  • 34. Kelsey said:

    Can't WAIT to read the rest. I had both my kids at a birthing center in a tub full of water. It was awesome. Oh, and FYI: I wear make-up, dye my hair, and shave. Everything.

    07.13.09 - 03:06 PM
  • 35. Katie said:

    um, the story was just getting good! come back! I can't wait to hear how it turns out.

    07.13.09 - 03:06 PM
  • 36. Becca said:

    Cliff-hanger!

    07.13.09 - 03:07 PM
  • 37. Vintage Kids' Books My Kid Loves said:

    Oh my God... i so hope this story ends the way i think it does. Seriously, I am crying right now with goosebumps up and down my arms. Four years ago my little one came into the world... and the only drug I popped were two Advil when it was over... It was the most amazing, incredible, sacred thing that has ever happened to me...

    Please let this story end good. If someone like Heather can help women stand up and not be afraid. Afraid like everyone tells us we are supposed to be.... the doctors, books, media... other women... then the world will be a better place indeed.

    I am so proud of you. Even if it you didn't see it through to the end, the fact that you even opened your mind to it is a miracle.

    Bravo sister. PLEASE WRITE THE END BEFORE I DIE OF SUSPENSE....

    07.13.09 - 03:08 PM
  • 38. Julie said:

    6 months pregnant here, and have been telling everyone that I have been practicing for drugs like an epidural my whole life, and that I have two arms, so if they can run drugs through 2 I.V.s...um, yeah...let's do that. Now I will probably read this book and start wearing Birkenstocks. Lord.

    07.13.09 - 03:08 PM
  • 39. mamagale said:

    I'll admit right up front: I'm a Mormon Mom of Many. Take that for what it's worth, but I had 8 children with NO medication (the first one only because I got to the hospital too late for them to give in to my pleas for drugs)and my recoveries were faster, our babies were alert, I could get up and go to the bathroom BY MYSELF and feel human. And I could get right to the good part immediately: cuddling that sweet new baby! So, in conclusion, I just want to say: Right ON Sister! (didn't intend to rattle on-just passionate about the subject)

    07.13.09 - 03:08 PM
  • 40. Yolanda said:

    Sacred and spiritual. I know exactly what you mean. I have never felt as connected and centered with my body as when I labored and delivered my daughter without drugs (two years ago last Thursday). I am so excited to read the rest of this story. Once again I found myself welling up in anticipation.

    Ricki Lake (or her publisher) has done an amazing thing by sending you that book. Your story is going to hit the ears of millions of women who know your story and know how unlikely a choice natural birth would seem to be for you. But because of you, millions of women are going to find out what a gift it is to themselves as Mothers, regardless of what debate their is about the benefits (and my personal belief is there are many) to babies.

    07.13.09 - 03:09 PM
  • 41. Wavybrains said:

    I respect you so, so, so much for admitting that you changed your mind. And then you did something about it. At 30 weeks pregnant. You ROCK.

    I can't wait to hear about the rest of the story, and I'm particularly interested for any emerging insights on how the difference in labor has on PPD.

    (And your post last week on your PPD this time around rocked big time too. Thank you from the bottom of my heart.)

    07.13.09 - 03:09 PM
  • 42. Elaine Benes said:

    Oh no Dooce, say it isn't so!

    07.13.09 - 03:09 PM
  • 43. Jessie Leigh said:

    Good God. Home births TERRIFY me. I'm looking forward to the rest of the story.

    07.13.09 - 03:09 PM
  • 44. Milo said:

    Who are you and where's Heather?
    Meh, I don't judge, you could've thrown up the baby, it would still be your beautiful Marlo, and I'd still love you and your blog.

    07.13.09 - 03:10 PM
  • 45. Darcy said:

    Holy crap, what a turnaround! Awesome! I went through that same obsessive researching when I was pregnant with my 2nd, and then STILL ended up with an epidural, just because (I later realized) my body really isn't happy being in a foreign place like a hospital when it's trying to give birth. Baby number 3 was born at home with a midwife, and it truly was overwhelmingly beautiful and spiritual.

    07.13.09 - 03:10 PM
  • 46. Amanda said:

    I had the most medical intervened birth possible (aside from c-section) with my first born and went on to have an AMAZING home birth with my second. If I have any more children (and barring any unforeseen medical issues) I will be having them at home as well.

    Also, I possess the righteous indignation, read it to piss me off gene as well. I mean...that's why I read your blog.

    I kid, I kid.

    07.13.09 - 03:12 PM
  • 47. Amanda said:

    Congratulations, Dooce! It is an AMAZING thing to say that you gave birth naturally. I did the same thing, just three months ago to a beautiful baby girl. (So, I am very much enjoying seeing your pictures and am really missing that newborn stage...it goes by so quickly.) I NEVER would have thought that I would have been able to do it...I cry at papercuts. And, EVERYONE thought I was crazy for wanting to go without drugs. People kept saying, "No one is going to give you an award for giving birth without an epidural." No, I didn't get an award, but I got a very beautiful baby girl who was extremely alert from the start and was breastfeeding within minutes. And, I tell EVERYONE I see that I gave birth to her without drugs. And, I also plan on holding it over her head until she's 52.

    I didn't read the Ricki Lake book, but I watched the video, and while some of it is extremely biased, I'm glad that I read it. Another good one (that is extremely hippy) is Ina May's Guide to Childbirth by Ina May Gaskin. I would recommend that any pregnant woman read something on natural childbirth so that they can make an informed decision on something that is so important.

    Congrats again, and can't wait to read Part 2...Part 3...and Part 4....

    07.13.09 - 03:13 PM
  • 48. Lulu said:

    holy CRAP that was educational. MAYBE I'll consider a home birth. in a million years.

    07.13.09 - 03:13 PM
  • 49. Summer said:

    Holy crap! I was so drawn into the story and then it was over! Can't wait for part two! I didn't see this coming at all!

    07.13.09 - 03:13 PM
  • 50. Jana said:

    Your bursting mammary ducts leaves me hungry fo'mo! tell marlo to hurry on up as i can't wait to read the rest. and as long as you had a bikini wax, homebirth crunchiness and unmedicated labors are all good. ;)

    07.13.09 - 03:14 PM
  • 51. Allison said:

    Edge. Of. My. Seat.

    07.13.09 - 03:15 PM
  • 52. Serial said:

    Your enthusiasm should be for sale. I'd buy it. I mean, if I could apply it to something awesomer than natural childbirth, like, to learning how to tango or something.

    Natural childbirth sounds like it sucks.

    07.13.09 - 03:16 PM
  • 53. Melissa said:

    I also had a medicalized first birth that inspired me to research natural alternatives for my second birth. We were so nervous about going to the hospital that I ended up having the baby at home by mistake. Afterwards, I wished we'd planned for a homebirth, because I didn't want to give birth without an attendant, but it was SO MUCH BETTER at home. The worst part was when the paramedics showed up. Looking forward to hearing the rest of the story!

    07.13.09 - 03:16 PM
  • 54. Bush Babe of Granite Glen said:

    As someone who has never had the option of natural childbirth, I am in awe. I fought long and hard with my second baby to have it naturally (as I have a reasonable pain tolerance I thought I could do it without drugs too... but what do I know?) but in the end, I bowed to the wishes of pretty much everyone else in my life (they like me alive apparently!) and went c-section again.

    Cannot wait to read how it all panned out for you. Brava!!!
    :-)
    BB

    07.13.09 - 03:16 PM
  • 55. Esther said:

    I am one of those NUTSOs who had two homebirths. No drugs, stitches done under the light of my own bedside lamp. I am also the least hemp wearing, whale music listening woman in the world. I did it because I, like you, had read so much about the over-medicalised nature of modern childbirth. Like you, my experiences were amazing. Snuggled up in my own warm house with my happy, alert, non drug affected moments old infants. Priceless!

    07.13.09 - 03:16 PM
  • 56. Amanda said:

    P.S. My hospital birth baby was 7lbs 8oz (was induced because he was going to be HUGE. *eye roll*) and I had a nasty little tear after it was all said and done.

    My home birth baby was 10lbs 40z, 22inches long, 16inch shoulders. No tearing. Whatsoever.

    I sparkly heart homebirth.

    07.13.09 - 03:16 PM
  • 57. Michelle said:

    and "Misconceptions" by Naomi Wolf! I will now add Ricki Lake's book to the list of books/movies I tell pregnant women (or thinking of being pregnant women, or men who may impregnate a woman, etc.) to read/watch. That was the starting point for me - congrats and can't wait to hear the rest of the story!

    07.13.09 - 03:17 PM
  • 58. Jenn said:

    I've been thinking about a natural birth and can't wait to hear the rest. I'm hoping it'll mention how you dealt with the actual labor pain...

    07.13.09 - 03:17 PM
  • 59. Amanda said:

    AWESOME. I am so glad you are posting about this!!! Before I was pregnant, I was all, "Epidural? You betcha!", but then I started to research like you did, and I was able to go throughout a 32 hour labor without pitocin, a C-section, episiotomy, or any intervention whatsoever (at the hospital too). It was the most empowering experience of my life, and I am so glad I had the birth experience I wanted. Congrats!!! :)

    07.13.09 - 03:18 PM
  • 60. Raezin said:

    I'm glad that you had such a strong spiritual experience with childbirth. If I remember my child's birth correctly, well, I wouldn't wish that kind of spiritual experience on my worst enemy!

    If I didn't have my daughter in a hospital, she would've died. If I didn't have my epidural, someone else would have.

    07.13.09 - 03:18 PM
  • 61. amanda said:

    uh...10lbs 4oz...not 40oz

    07.13.09 - 03:19 PM
  • 62. Lara said:

    My first two children were born naturally, albeit in a hospital environment. Not an experience I'd have missed for the world, but my last two children were born with epidurals and smiles... I'm just sayin'.

    07.13.09 - 03:21 PM
  • 63. Caitlyn Nicholas said:

    My first birth was a vile experience with no pain relief and the baby stuck in the birth canal for 40 minutes (in a hospital) and ended in forceps and a spinal tap. I was badly traumatised.

    I had an epidural for the second and I found that experience incredibly empowering, fulfilling and (the best part) not stressful or painful.

    So I don't think its the pain relief that "dis-empowers" women giving birth. I think the feeling of disempowerment comes more when you find yourself in a situation where you are in pain and feel helpless about it.

    Thanks for the great blog - we saw you on tv in Australia a few weeks ago (on Oprah) :)

    Cait.

    07.13.09 - 03:22 PM
  • 64. Kris said:

    What's the thing with duck farts? Obviously I'm not in on the joke.

    07.13.09 - 03:22 PM
  • 65. Darcy said:

    Oh, and to add another book recommendation to the list that seems to be compiling in the comments, "The Thinking Woman's Guide to a Better Birth" by Henci Goer. Facts, straight up, unbiased.

    07.13.09 - 03:23 PM
  • 66. Meltron said:

    THANK YOU!!! For sharing, for being open-minded (even if it was motivated by anger and stubborness) and for sharing this documentary and book with your readers. I'm 7 months pregnant, planning a birth center birth with a team of midwives and no drugs and I try to tell everyone I meet that the MOST important thing to do when deciding on a birth plan is just to read. Do the research....there are options out there. I'm fortunate enough to live in Seattle where midwives are having to turn patients away (crazy birkenstock wearing, flannel loving, eco-friendly, city...that I LOVE!!). Not all woman will be fortunate enough to have a choice of midwives, doulas, birth centers, etc...that I did, but if you do, just check it out.

    Can't wait to hear how the story ends. Marlo is lucky to be a part of your beautiful family.

    07.13.09 - 03:23 PM
  • 67. Kickypants said:

    Thank you, thank you, thank you. I have just done more for the the case against medicalized birth than you will ever understand. You have just opened thousands of womens' minds to the possibility of a different kind of birth. Thank you. I'm so glad you had a great experience and I can't wait to read the rest of the story!

    07.13.09 - 03:24 PM
  • 68. trish said:

    God, you DO NOT KNOW how timely this post is for me. My friend just had a 36 hour labor followed by a c-section, and she's like, DO THE EPIDURAL. And weirdly enough, I'm thinking to myself...No, I want a natural childbirth. I'm as non-hippy as they come, and as much as I hate pain, I can't believe that there's not better things happening with midwives and water births and all that good stuff. AND, my friend's new bebe is having a hard time suckling. And apparently there's a connection with epidurals and breast feeding being hard. ACK! You can't make us wait for the rest of the story! I must have the rest of the story so I can be morally smug!

    07.13.09 - 03:26 PM
  • 69. Mona said:

    Kudos. If I ever decide to have another child, I think I will end up going this route because I've done (semi) natural and c-section. I'm so cool on the dr. cutting and stitching up my vajayjay, the extra long needle to the spine and the obtrusiveness of some of the hospital staff. And the drugs didn't really help anyway.

    Btw, your post flashed me to the time I was in the car with my son's godfather and my milk sprayed everywhere..dashboard, windshield and both side windows. He was so traumatized....he still brings it up to this day and my son is 16.

    07.13.09 - 03:27 PM
  • 70. Daena said:

    Yay, Heather!

    You go girl!

    I can't wait to hear the rest of the story.

    Much Love,
    Daena in Queens, NY!

    07.13.09 - 03:27 PM
  • 71. Alexis said:

    Yay! I had planned to have child #1 naturally, but a mid-preg kidney operation and a 30hr labor kind of derailed that idea. I did however, successfully have a natural childbirth with child#2. I was in labor for 5hrs, that's it. It was kind of funny really. I ended up in the back seat of my dh's subaru, draped over my birthing ball, trying to survive the monday morning rush hour traffic ride to the hospital. I must have been going through transition at that point, loads of fun, I tell ya. We get there, they check me, I'm at a 10. Wohoooo!! Nothing like showing up to the hospital ready to push. 40 minutes later, my son was born. It was worth every minute. Can't wait to hear the rest of the story!!

    07.13.09 - 03:28 PM
  • 72. Jeanie said:

    It's so great to hear you say this . . . I went through almost the exact same epiphany early in my pregnancy, and while I'm only 30 weeks along now, so have not as yet experienced the labor part, I have done so much reading (all the books you mentioned and so many more) that I'm almost eager for the natural birth experience. Not that I'm not expecting it to be tremendously hard work and lots of pain, but I'm hoping that it's also an amazing, empowering experience. And hearing your story gives me hope.

    07.13.09 - 03:29 PM
  • 73. Alysha said:

    seriously.. I love reading everything you write... you tell the truth like no other person. You have me so pulled in that I can't wait to hear about the rest of your birth story!

    07.13.09 - 03:30 PM
  • 74. Ashley said:

    Oh goodness! Business of Being Born is amazing. Also, changed my life. Hoping for a birthing center birth next go-round...feeling incredibly guilty about my epidural and c-section!

    07.13.09 - 03:31 PM
  • 75. Golden said:

    This post is useless without a photo of Marlo. :)

    Seriously though, way to go! I'm proud of you.

    07.13.09 - 03:31 PM
  • 76. Jessica said:

    I am the lame 40 week pregnant woman in Seattle who emailed you this morning begging for the birth story. I'm sure the timing was coincidental, but thank you so much for posting this today, you made my month. I am DYING for part 2 (and 3, 4, whatever)- cannot wait to hear the rest of your story.
    I had my 1st daughter in a birth center with a midwife and sacred and spiritual are exactly the right words. I am so totally not a hippy, and 99% of my friends still think I'm crazy for that choice, but it was truly the most incredible day of my life (and my husband's), and we were both on a high for a week after. Our second daughter was born in a hospital after pitocin but with no epidural (although I was screaming for one-just not enough time), and although the end result was perfection (my sweet girl #2), the birth experience cannot compare. The second, induced hospital birth was so...blah. I agree with everything you say about birth in the US and am so, so happy to see you writing about it here, where you can truly open the minds of so many. I know the rest of your birth story will be equally inspirational and exhilirating - can't wait to hear it!!

    07.13.09 - 03:31 PM
  • 77. Tara said:

    My husband and I watched The Business of Being Born when I was about 7 months pregnant with my second. It (along with some other reading) influenced me so much that I ended up ditching my OB who wasn't very natural-birthing friendly and switched to a certified nurse midwife who had hospital privileges, hired a doula, and wound up with an awesome experience. And then I started writing completely in run-on sentences. Can't wait to read the rest of your story!!

    07.13.09 - 03:31 PM
  • 78. Deborah said:

    Thanks for the post - I've been anxious to hear this story. I had two c-sections so can only have the experience vicariously.

    07.13.09 - 03:32 PM
  • 79. malin said:

    Just gave birth 2 months ago, was all ready for the drugs when the epidural failed completely. I had to do it all natural and honestly it was the best gift that crappy anesthesiologist ever gave anyone. It was a beautiful and empowering moment, I felt like I could climb Everest afterward.

    07.13.09 - 03:32 PM
  • 80. Deborah said:

    Oh, and you were great on GMA!

    07.13.09 - 03:32 PM
  • 81. Acher said:

    I do things all the time just so I can be pissed off, be "right," etc. Drives my husband nuts. He's been known to call me a martyr a time or 400.

    Oh, and though I have no babies (yet), I am totally on board with natural birth and am very interested in homebirth, though I have a feeling my neighbors in my condo building might not be so thrilled with that. A midwife came and talked to one of my classes in college, and it was totally eye opening! My friends all have had epidurals and thing that I am certifiably crazy.

    07.13.09 - 03:32 PM
  • 82. Jordan said:

    Heather-
    I love that documentary and that book! I totally have a girl crush on Ricki and have since that documentary came out. I went alone when I was 7 months pregnant and I wish my husband had gone with me. It made me truly believe in my ability to have a completely natural birth.

    Alas, I failed miserably, and there were a lot of things at work in the universe that contributed to my c-section, and it wasn't just being in a hospital. However, because of all of the things I would do differently, and the icky experience I had, I am so proud of you for having a good one. Jealous, but proud nontheless. Yay! :)

    07.13.09 - 03:33 PM
  • 83. Becca said:

    I am SO glad you saw that documentary. I saw it in nursing school and I think it's one of the most intelligent, convincing arguments for natural childbirth.

    Can't wait to hear the rest!!

    07.13.09 - 03:33 PM
  • 84. Ali said:

    Yes! Brava, Heather, it makes me so happy to hear this. I had a hospital birth but my philosophy during the pregnancy was, 'The less the doctors do, the better.'

    07.13.09 - 03:33 PM
  • 85. Amanda said:

    Hmmm, I have mixed feelings on this. I love reading your site, but as I started to read your post, I was all "oh crap, here goes someone else on this topic....." I am so happy you got the birth you wanted. Really, truly, happy. I am happy for ANY woman that achieves the birth that she wants and is important to her. And I do not mean to undermine the importance of the actual birth in any way. But HOLY CRAP I want to run and hide from all this emphasis on the EXACT means in which our children enter this world. Sometimes women get the birth of their dreams and that's totally awesome. But sometimes our children with enter the world in varied ways that are not of our time and choosing. I have had a couple of those births and perhaps this makes me jaded. Perhaps it is just because I have lived "on the other side" so to speak.

    Women should feel empowered to have the birth they want and they should be supported. I just feel very strongly that should include all kinds of births, natural, epidural and yes, even c-sections. And this rant is not toward you specifically at all, but Ricky Lake kinda irritates me. Success is measured in many ways. Sometimes I feel she is more, natural birth equals success and awesome and everything else is......meh. Of course there is much more to it than that. And I have watched her documentary. That's all I am saying. I get too riled up about it and could say so much more. So I'll just stop:) Looking forward to part 2.

    07.13.09 - 03:34 PM
  • 86. Laura Trevey said:

    Love reading your blog! So glad I just found you...

    07.13.09 - 03:35 PM
  • 87. Tiffany said:

    That's so great Heather! I agree completely with you, although most of my medical colleagues scoff and make jokes. Congratulations on having such a great, empowering experience, and having things go beautifully just the way you wanted them too. Another great book, besides the one you mentioned is Henci Goer's "The Thinking Womans Guide to a Better Birth." I can't wait to hear the rest of your story!

    07.13.09 - 03:36 PM
  • 88. Halala Mama said:

    I am looking forward to reading the second part - I went without pain med for the first 10 hours of induced labor. I finally had an epidural before an emergency c-section and it was so absolutely hellish that I would do anything to avoid that in the future. It couldn't be avoided in my situation that time, but I'm glad you were able to avoid it.

    07.13.09 - 03:36 PM
  • 89. Christian said:

    Awesome! You rock! I am so glad that you are sharing this story, and I know that because the best way to inspire is by example, that you will positively impact lots of pregos out there. This may sound cheesy, but I am so proud of you!

    07.13.09 - 03:36 PM
  • 90. Nikki said:

    WOW, that is awesome ... My girlfriends and I just saw the same documentary and we can't wait to go buy our kiddie pools and set them up in our living rooms for our own home births!!! Ok, just kidding, but I am totally on the midwife/natural birth bandwagon, it really is LIFE CHANGING information. Can't wait to hear the rest of your adventure!!

    07.13.09 - 03:37 PM
  • 91. Mary@Holy Mackerel said:

    Love your stuff, even if it makes me flinch at times.

    Can't wait for Part II!!

    Both my births were natural, the first was terrible, and the second joyous. I had a doula and more support (and knowledge and confidence) the second time around. Not sure if that made the difference, but I'm sure glad it happened the way it did.

    07.13.09 - 03:38 PM
  • 92. areader said:

    thanks for sharing, but I'm hoping the rest of the story isn't pervaded by smugness and self-righteousness as so many natural birth stories are. Childbirth is an accomplishment and awe-inspiring moment, no matter how it runs its course. Remember too that second births are typically much easier, faster and more predictable than first births, which makes an attempt at a natural birth much more feasible.

    That said, kudos to you for your decision and congratulations that things worked out as you had hoped.

    07.13.09 - 03:38 PM
  • 93. Stupendousness said:

    I do not ever want to be pregnant or give birth, but if I did, I would do some variation of homebirth. I've read about natural birthing centers, and I would probably prefer that to being at home. I definitely would not want to be in a hospital, which is the most hated place for me.

    But mostly what scared me about birth in a hospital is birth "rape." I know that's a controversial term, but however you choose to label it, I don't think anyone can deny that a large group of medical staff performing procedures and giving you drugs without your consent is completely unacceptable.

    Also in a hospital, I fear I would be treated more like an object. To the nurses and even doctor, I would just be something to clean up after, to poke and prod to write down vitals. And that's understandable to an extent because they're understaffed and overworked. I just know that for me, being treated with respect is very important.

    I do get angry when people say that those who are pro-home birth or pro-midwife-assisted birth are just crunchy liberal people, as if we go along with whatever is "natural," as if we haven't researched the issue and decided we know what is best for ourselves, not tradition.

    07.13.09 - 03:38 PM
  • 94. Peg said:

    I'm old enough to be your mother (but I'm not!) and my children were born au natural (in hospitals) over 30 years ago, the first using hypnoanesthesia. Thank goodness someone with an audience is bringing the over-medicalization of childbirth back for discussion! We thought childbirth was over-medicalized in our day and it's much worse now. I've witnessed this incredible change in intervention and in fear on the part of mothers-to-be over the course of my career as an RN as well as through the births of my grandchildren. Congrats on your wonderful experience and the birth of another beautiful daughter! They are very fortunate to have such a smart, funny, and best of all, honest Mom! Love your blog!

    07.13.09 - 03:39 PM
  • 96. newbuffalomom said:

    Had two normal, medical births at hospitals. Then I had two all natural homebirths. NO contest. I will not willingly give birth in a hospital again. :-)

    07.13.09 - 03:39 PM
  • 97. Cheryl said:

    There is nothing more empowering, amazing, spiritual - you name it - than natural childbirth. I had two home births, one unplanned (oops!), the next one planned, and this was after having the traditional GIVE ME THE EPIDURAL NOW! delivery with my first. Now, I'm the least granola person on the planet. But I am now a HUGE advocate of drug-free birth, especially at home. The Business of Being Born only helped fuel my fire when people (re: my mother) gave me a hard time about my choice to have a home birth.

    The best part is, as a mother to a daughter, I showed my 3 1/2 year-old exactly how strong women can be in the biggest miracle there is: childbirth. (She came in immediately after her brother was born and asked "Mommy? Why are you crying? Because pushing a baby out of your bagina is hard work?")

    Congratulations and thank you for using your forum to bring this information to all your readers.

    07.13.09 - 03:39 PM
  • 98. carrie said:

    Can't wait to hear part 2, I'm completely fascinated by birth stories lately. If you have a moment, I think you'd really appreciate this one, esp given your desire for a natural birth. This is from the father's perspective & is just awesome:

    http://pacingthepanicroom.blogspot.com/2009/07/birth-of-tessa-tangerine....

    Also, he did a fantastic photographic maternity series, really really good stuff.

    xoxoxo

    07.13.09 - 03:40 PM
  • 99. Anonymous said:

    I worked at a maternity store for years
    heard HORROR stories and great ones too, as you can well imagine

    NEVER read a book (except for books on Nursing) used books for advice on ONLY the info I wanted or needed
    but did get a DOULA

    DOULAS ROCK- seriously!
    I LOVED/LOVE mine and would HIGHLY recommend them!

    I have two lovely born at the hospital but au natural babies
    and would not trade it for the world

    my reasons were different...HATE needles and the thought of not moving below the waist TERRIFYING
    I stub my toe and get sick but this..THIS I KNEW I could do and did

    so congrats to you
    cannot wait to hear the rest of your birth story

    07.13.09 - 03:41 PM
  • 100. Lisa said:

    I feel a book coming on....Patchouli Birth! How I did it without Vodka!

    I had a c-section and one natural. Absolutely hated both. Am glad I can never get pregnant again. I did not find birth to be any sort of spiritual experience.

    Now when my Dad passed away, it was the most incredible spiritual experience I ever had. I felt honored to watch and feel his soul leave his body. It was almost like his soul came to me. Just awesome. I am hoping my kids will get to experience the same thing.

    Can't wait for the next chapter, Heather. Great reading!

    07.13.09 - 03:41 PM
  • 101. Stephanie said:

    I can't wait to read the rest of your story! I just read the book and saw the documentary. We are thinking it's about time for baby #2 but I need to know I have a "better" plan in place than with baby #1. The labor wasn't so traumatic, it was everything that happened right after the epidural. You know how the snowball effect works, right?!?! Let's just say it was the biggest snowball known to man and I want to avoid that with our next child.

    07.13.09 - 03:41 PM
  • 102. Courtney said:

    I was my mom's labor coach for her natural birth to my 10.5 lb baby brother 14 years ago(I was 14). She had me there in part to make me not want to have babies for a long time, but in part for her own little campaign for natural births. I saw her do it, with minimal screaming and teeth-gnashing and realized even at 14 that I too could do it someday. So that's my eventual plan and I am glad to hear it was wonderful for you as well.

    plus the idea of a needle in my spine is g-ross and bothers me more than the thought of losing an arm or something.

    07.13.09 - 03:42 PM
  • 103. MereMortal said:

    Heather,
    I'm the crazyass who emailed you, in sincerity, and with a wide open heart, a few times saying things like "Please, can I be your doula? Oh won't you have your baby at home?".

    When I first read the news that you birthed Marlo with all of your sacred power and spiritual might, I about fell to my knees in utter bliss for YOU.

    And now this story, which I've been waiting for. I can't summon words. I await anxiously. And I'm over the moon that it's given us natural/home birthers even a teeny Dooce nod. I mean, that's cool. That's actually been a dream of mine...get Dooce to endorse supported, loving, powerful natural birth and "BAM! There goes Medicalized birth forever!" Um, yeah, you are pretty powerful.

    Enough of my rambling. I can't wait for details.
    You rock, birth warrior!

    Leigh, your not-doula but doula in spirit
    PS (I secretly also dreamed you'd somehow, last minute, choose a homebirth.)

    07.13.09 - 03:42 PM
  • 104. sarah said:

    i have never had a child, and perhaps i never will, but i, too, watched ricki's documentary and it totally changed my thinking about homebirth, midwives, and the whole 'business' of the hospitals. having worked in hospitals in the past (good ones, even), it's clear to me that SO much of what is done in those institutions has much to do about the almighty dollar and so little to do with what's good for the actual patient (imagine that!). if nothing else, it definitely makes you think!

    love your stories; can't wait to read the next part:)

    07.13.09 - 03:44 PM
  • 105. Regan said:

    I'm shocked! Not because I even know you and think you are lying about the pain, but that's just it, the pain! When I had my son two years ago, labor was very hard for me. It was somewhat short I guess (4 hours) but it was hands down the worst, indescribable pain that I ever experienced and I thought I was going to die. So, that said, I am planning on having another baby, I'm not pregnant yet, but my husband and I are in negotiations, and I will surely pick up a copy of this book if you say it's THIS good. Because I wanted to do it naturally, but mostly, I wanted some way to work through my pain, because my only form of relief came through the epidural and even then I was very uncomfortable. BUT if you say so........ (;

    07.13.09 - 03:45 PM
  • 106. Tara said:

    I read a bunch of natural birth stories on mothering.com to get an idea of what I would be in for. Surprisingly, although I am all about natural birth, the stories that made me feel better about everything were the ones where the natural birth didn't result in bliss. Knowing that things may not go according to dreams and plan and knowing it will be okay and there may be disappointments, put me at ease. No one is less of a mother for having more medical intervention, but reaching for the ideal of a natural birth should be a societal norm!

    Like other posters, I am grateful for you publicly putting your story out there and giving this option such a voice. Thank you!!

    07.13.09 - 03:45 PM
  • 107. Callista said:

    Thank you so much for writing about this experience!

    I too saw the Epstein and Lake's documentary, "The Business of Being Born," and like you, it completely and totally changed my life. Mind you, I am currently a 21-year-old college student who is not planning on having children for quite some time, but I think homebirthing and midwifery is something every woman she know about. I spent an entire term researching the topic, writing a paper, and presenting my discoveries in my classes. It is such amazing, empowering information to have.

    Thank you for taking the time to read their book. Thank you for being open-minded enough to consider a home birth. And perhaps most of all, thank you for sharing your experiences with the world! I'm sure that, like Lake and Epstein, your posts will change someone's life.

    07.13.09 - 03:46 PM
  • 108. Ginger said:

    I am so jealous. Once you have one c-section you'll be lucky if they let you go into labor on your own . . . I am green wtih envy and delighted for you all at the same time, because you got the birth experience I dreamed of. Well done, Dooce!

    07.13.09 - 03:46 PM
  • 109. Anonymous said:

    I saw the movie based on that book this weekend and thought of you the whole time. I'm not having children of my own, and I'm no fan of the whole pain thing, but after watching the documentary, I'd have a natural birth for sure. Congratulations!

    07.13.09 - 03:46 PM
  • 110. Jeni said:

    I had 4 kiddos all in the hospital....the idea of home birthing always scared the shit out of me. So did the idea of nursing, yeah I didn't do that either.

    07.13.09 - 03:46 PM
  • 111. falwyn said:

    In all honesty (and how embarrassing it is) I am cheering partly because yay for you! but also because I'm just so glad to get to hear your unique voice and take on this subject. I will come up with a list of other subjects for you to write on, I'm sure you're happy to hear it. ;) Can't wait for the next part.

    07.13.09 - 03:47 PM
  • 112. Rachel said:

    Heather, I'm *SOOOO* glad that this birth went so well! I can't wait for Parts 2, 3, 4, and 5!!! :-)

    07.13.09 - 03:47 PM
  • 113. Charley said:

    Yay Heather! Now PLEASE POST PART 2!!!!

    07.13.09 - 03:48 PM
  • 114. Keep On S'myelin! said:

    I bow down to all of you who go drug free. Kudos to you! I'm not sure I could do it.

    Can't wait for part deux!

    07.13.09 - 03:50 PM
  • 115. Bella said:

    I'm not pregnant...but I'll be netflixing the movie for sure. Can't wait to hear about the rest of the story!

    Oh and please tell us about when you take your comp back to the apple store and tell the geniuses there that your macbook is fried due to lactation. That'll be a classic no doubt.

    07.13.09 - 03:50 PM
  • 116. Jaclyn said:

    I am HAPPY for you....but a little sad too. I think that the natural childbirth option is great, but some moms really dont get to make that choice. Some of the issue I took with that movie (loved it, by the way) was that it makes the non-natural births sounds "less-than." I know that isnt the intent--or maybe it is, but it does feel that way to me as a c-section'd mom. When I hear from champions of natural birth, I wonder if I am supposed to feel bad about my own experience? For what its worth, I took natural birthing classes, a natural birth just wasn't in the cards for me.

    07.13.09 - 03:51 PM
  • 117. thatgirlblogs said:

    I had a natural birth and it sucked rocks. But, once it's over you have other things to worry about. Which is wonderful.

    07.13.09 - 03:53 PM
  • 118. Professional Critic said:

    Can't wait to hear the rest of the story! Though I don't have children and generally believe any way babies make it into the world safely is okay by me, The Business of Being Born was an incredible eye opener about the over-medicalization of labor. Thanks for sharing your thought process.

    07.13.09 - 03:53 PM
  • 119. Nancy W said:

    Congratulations Heather!! You had what I call a BREAKTHROUGH! I am so happy to read this I had to say THANKYOU! So many of my friends have had "natural childbirth" and even tho it is not the same experience for everyone, it is the first part of having a choice in how we do "birth" our children. I am so happy for you!

    07.13.09 - 03:55 PM
  • 120. Eden said:

    My favorite post I've ever read of yours. Of course, I'm pro-natural childbirth and pro-doula and I just love hearing about your own change of heart when it came to this subject. Plus, I've always thought you were a pretty spiritual person simply because you react so strongly to spirituality and religion.

    I can't wait to read part two!

    07.13.09 - 03:55 PM
  • 121. Candy Stick Lane said:

    I work in a genetics center and we are VERY pro natural childbirth I have a doula in the office next to me -my kids are 16, 9 and 8 but I want to have another and she has given me some great books to read - you're right the statistics are insane- im so excited to hear the rest of the story :D

    07.13.09 - 03:57 PM
  • 122. Carrie at Rhubarb Sky said:

    Yay! I'm so excited to hear how everything went. I'm also really pleased to see someone that has as much public influence as you taking resources like The Business of Being Born and Birthing from Within so seriously.
    I had a beautiful natural birth. It was hard damn work, but certainly nothing to be fearful of, and I'm so glad for the experience.

    07.13.09 - 03:57 PM
  • 123. Leila said:

    Congrats! It's wonderful to hear that you had such a great birth, and also wonderful that you were able to change your plan so late in the game. I've had two drug free deliveries, one at the hospital and one at home, and I wouldn't change anything about either. It was hard, but so worth it. I live in Ontario, where midwifery care is covered by our provincial health care plan. I feel so fortunate to have had this option, but it sounds like your OBGYN was just as supportive. Lucky girl :)

    07.13.09 - 03:58 PM
  • 124. mags said:

    I am a convert to natural childbirth too! My first baby was induced in hospital 10 days late. Like a domino effect, we suffered through every intervention possible, barring a c-section and most complications resulting from the interventions such as hemorrhaging, blood pressure drop, and many others. It was a train wreck and a bloodbath. He was a big boy, 10 lbs with a 15 1/2 head, but I was having no trouble at all til the epidural was administered. I still have an episiotomy scar on my inner thigh even though it was 19 yrs ago. I swore afterwards he was going to be an only child.

    He was the best baby ever, as perfect and happy as a human can be, so I later decided to do it again but entirely differently. The next two babies were also born in hospital (I have two hour labors and the only birthing center was too far away) but had wonderful midwives, no meds, no episotomies. I was walking to the shower within two hours, and the babies were alert and nursing within minutes. They were 9 lbs and 9 lbs 8 oz each so the size was not significantly different. If I could have done a birthing center I would have done it without question.

    I have so much trust and confidence in and respect for my body as a result of these births, and I would do it again in a heartbeat if my life allowed it. This was especially powerful for me since I also suffer from chronic profound depression and anxiety and had often felt like my body/brain was flawed because of it. (I have been living better with pharmaceuticals since the 80's!)

    Congratulations, Heather and all the Armstrongs!

    07.13.09 - 03:59 PM
  • 125. Labradoris said:

    I love it when you hit your writing pace. It is thrilling to behold! Excited for the rest of the parts. :)

    07.13.09 - 03:59 PM
  • 126. Lori said:

    When I was pregnant with my second daughter, I wanted to arrange for the epidural in the hospital parking lot. I loved reading your post and can't wait for Part 2. It's so great that you admit openly about changing your mind about something you already had a strong opinion on. I love reading your blog. It encourages people to be authentic.

    07.13.09 - 03:59 PM
  • 127. Mia said:

    YES! It sounds AWESOME! Can't wait to read the rest.

    My family thought I was bat shit insane when I told them I was having my first child at home. (I'm not exactly granola material)
    But it was so peaceful and empowering. It is a memory I will have for the rest of my life and I sincerely hope other women who have the inclination will have access to good info so they can make an informed choice.

    07.13.09 - 03:59 PM
  • 128. Gail said:

    Oh, I *remember* those days of looking down at my breasts and knowing that they had their own agenda and then just giving in and going "Mooooooooooooooooo". The oooooh and owwwwww of fullness and the sweet release and aaaaaahs of successful nursing. I actually miss the absurdity of those days. Thanks for the reminder!

    07.13.09 - 03:59 PM
  • 129. Carolina said:

    Dear Heather,

    I have followed your writing since god knows when. I am Chilean (living in Chile).
    I am so proud of what you have achieved throughout these years. My mother suffered a very deep and difficult depression a few years ago and I know how hard it can be... so I am very happy to see how happy you are now enjoying the health and love of your two children and your incredible husband.
    I hope one day I can be as strong as you are!
    You are my hero!
    Love, Carolina.

    07.13.09 - 03:59 PM
  • 130. BOSSY said:

    And now the Outback Steakhouse has its new t-shirt saying.

    07.13.09 - 04:00 PM
  • 131. Rebecca (Ramblings by Reba) said:

    I've never given birth. I've never been pregnant.

    BUT.

    I watched "The Business of Being Born" and LOVED it. I recently checked out that Ricki Lake book and look forward to reading it. I just reserved "Birthing from Within," because it sounds like something I'd like.

    Way to go, you!

    BTW, you might also like the book "Baby Catcher." It's about a lay midwife. In fact, based on what I read here, I bet you'd LOVE it.

    Yay again, you!

    07.13.09 - 04:00 PM
  • 132. Nikki said:

    I haven't even finished reading this post yet and I had to comment. I'm pregnant with my first, and a friend of mine recommended that I check out the midwives at UCLA. I, too, had always thought that "midwives" and "homebirth" were something for crazy hippy people who didn't shave very often.

    But from there, I went and rented The Business of Being Born - I was probably only about 2 months in when I watched it, and I was HORRIFIED, after watching that movie. Horrified at the state of birth in the United States, that is.

    I immediately decided that I was going au natural, using midwives and I have to say - considering this is my first child, with all the research and reading I've been doing about natural childbirth, I'm not the slightest bit scared. I'm not even afraid of all the pain - especially after hearing about how all the drugs, and that nasty pitocin they give women, actually makes the pain WORSE.

    There's so much research to prove that giving birth naturally is SO MUCH safer & better for your baby, and isn't that who you should be most concerned about?

    Anyway, so - YAY! Thank you so much for writing about this, because I feel like the truth about drugs/birth/natural childbirth really needs to be told to more women. Before someone suggested the midwives to me, it never really occurred to me that I had other options.

    07.13.09 - 04:01 PM
  • 133. forkboy1965 said:

    That's nothin'....I once ate two Whoppers meals and didn't burp once!

    07.13.09 - 04:03 PM
  • 134. Amy said:

    I sincerely believe if they could capture and bottle the amazing cocktail of hormones you get after a natural birth, it would be illegal. THE HIGH IS THAT FUCKING AMAZING.

    07.13.09 - 04:03 PM
  • 135. kim said:

    For me it's all about the woman having the power to make her own choice about how her birth should go, and not turn all the decisions over to the doctor's and labor nurses.

    I started out like you with my first--really wanting a delivery without drugs--but it just so happened that the baby was transverse (big bummer for a natural childbirth) so I ended up having a c-section. My doula was worried that I would feel like a failure, but I was actually SO thankful for modern medicine because 100 years ago I would have been one of those women who died in childbirth (and the baby as well). Because I was involved in the decisions I had no regrets, even tho I ended up with the c-section I was adamantly opposed to in the months before my baby's birth. In the end I had a healthy baby and I never felt like I was at the mercy of the medical establishment.

    07.13.09 - 04:04 PM
  • 136. Holly said:

    Oh wow didn't see this one coming. Can't wait for the rest of the story. I've had all my children natural (the last two at home..including a 10lb 4oz baby while standing in my bathroom). Now if we could get you to open your mind up about vaccinations. Baby steps I guess.

    07.13.09 - 04:04 PM
  • 137. RichardK said:

    You are a wonderful writer. I don't get too excited with the dog pictures and the artsy craftsy stuff, but it's a nanoscopic price to pay for having the pleasure of reading your posts. Please, whatever you do, don't stop writing. BTW, what's the trackback to the post on duck farts?

    07.13.09 - 04:07 PM
  • 138. Watson said:

    Awesome, Heather!

    I didn't think I could love you any more, and then you wrote this post.

    I planned on a intervention-free birth for a long time, reading everything I could find (esp. the Ina May Gaskin books), taking a Hypnobirthing class and also hiring a doula.

    But then my OBGYN was all, HELLO! You're having twins and that's a whole OTHER deal.

    And then I ended up getting sick in my 38th week and a scheduled c-section was penciled in to my Kate Spade organizer.

    I went from home birth candlelit tub birth to a planned section, but in the end both of my babies were born healthy and that's what mattered.

    I can't wait to read the rest of your story!!

    07.13.09 - 04:08 PM
  • 139. Roryx said:

    I do the same angry thing with books and movies. I will get so worked up about a book and I just can't give it up! I read Twilight because I had nothing else to read at the time and I HATED IT. I then of course read the rest of the series so I could hate it and critize more thouroughly.

    07.13.09 - 04:10 PM
  • 140. Gabby said:

    OMG OMG OMG THAT MAKES ME SO HAPPY.

    I'm only a lowly 17 year old but I would desperately love to be a homebirth midwife one day, so obviously I'm a massive advocate of natural birth. When I read you were pregnant this time around, I was actually convinced that exactly this would happen to you. I'm just so glad you took the initiative to educate yourself and had the birth you wanted :D

    And yeah, those statistics are terrifying. C-section rates up to 80% in some states, where the maximum safe rate is 15%? Ow.

    07.13.09 - 04:10 PM
  • 141. Aljolynn said:

    Ummm...I seriously laughed so hard that it took 10 minutes...that's right 10 MINUTES! to stop laughing. Note that I am at work reading this....good thing no one else is in the office today, otherwise I might have been fired.

    Thankfully Satan decided to spit you out of hell because the people here on Earth reallye enjoy reading your blog.

    Can't wait to read part 2.

    Cheers!

    07.13.09 - 04:12 PM
  • 142. Joy said:

    I went through a similar shift, and ended up with a totally natural homebirth. It was safe, it was awesome, and I felt empowered to make a peaceful, responsible choice.

    It's my hope that every woman has the opportunity to make that choice--whether it finds her in a remote cabin in the woods, or with every medical intervention she can get her hands on--and to feel totally comfortable with her birth decisions.

    07.13.09 - 04:12 PM
  • 143. Shylo said:

    I also changed my provider at 30 weeks after asking the same questions. I had midwives deliver my son at a hospital. It rocked and I highly recommend it to others.

    07.13.09 - 04:13 PM
  • 144. monique said:

    Interesting comments re: the bikini wax as prep for birth (#50).

    I forgot that waxing was a critical step to labour preparation. Since having a sparkly clean bikini line is going to make a big difference when you're pushing so hard you're shitting yourself.

    PEOPLE. WE HAVE PUBIC HAIR. Get over it!

    07.13.09 - 04:13 PM
  • 145. Kirsten said:

    I just did a little happy dance reading this. I had this epiphany when I pregnant the second time (the first ended in miscarriage, and I had a horrible experience with an OB). And it really is a personal epiphany. And I LOVE when other people have the same thing happen. Can't wait to hear the rest of the story.

    07.13.09 - 04:15 PM
  • 146. Mo said:

    *shock*
    Rikki Lake? I had no idea.

    My first (only) childbirth was natural by default. It really IS everything they say it is and more.

    07.13.09 - 04:15 PM
  • 147. Coyote said:

    All 4 of my births were natural. The first took place in a non-hospital birth center, and the other three were at home. The home births were much better, even with my 10-pound #2. I've always been of the mind that all women would prefer a natural birth, and only choose drugs and/or intervention if absolutely necessary. Apparently, it's the other way around! Good on ya, Heather! I'm glad you had the balls to buck the trend :-)

    07.13.09 - 04:16 PM
  • 148. Megan said:

    The only things that could have thrilled me more about this post would have been if 1)the rest was already written and 2)I had been your doula. And I mean that in the least-stalkerish way possible.

    As a hippy-crunchy-crazy-homebirthin-doula, I'll say nothing makes me more excited than seeing women take back their births.

    07.13.09 - 04:16 PM
  • 149. Heather said:

    My fiancee and I watched the Biz of Being Born a couple of years ago, and it completely blew us away. We are both from MO (a state in which until pretty recently midwives weren't even allowed to practice except in conjunction with/under the care of an OBGYN). We recommend the movie to people all the time--it really opened our eyes to the powerful experience that childbirth can be. If/when we have kids, we are totally on board w/natural (and preferably) home birth. It is rad to see the dialogue about this opening up!

    07.13.09 - 04:17 PM
  • 150. Elizabeth_K said:

    Wow! Totally unexpected, and possibly ... inspiring? I'm 26 weeks pregnant and I'm not SWEARING to anything, but it sounds ... intriguing. Tell more!

    07.13.09 - 04:17 PM
  • 151. Trish said:

    Dude.

    I didn't do any planning at all. That is awesome that you had such a great plan! I knew I wanted to try going natural, but I was sure I woud chicken out.

    My second birth was a natural birth and it was the best experience. I wanted to kill people after the first time. I was in hell. The recovery SUCKED. But when I had my second naturally, oh man, I recovered so quick and I felt like Superwoman!

    Best experience ever and yes, I'm describing childbirth. WEIRD!

    07.13.09 - 04:17 PM
  • 152. neverbeenbarbie said:

    Yay Dooce! Heather, I am so happy that you had such a wonderful birth experience.

    I had both my boys at home -- made the decision with my first after I read "Ina May Gaskin's Guide to Childbirth." I approached the book with the same trepidation you describe in your post but by the end of it -- after reading dozens of birth stories written by the mothers, midwives, and even the fathers which really served to demystify the whole birthing process for me -- I realized that having a natural childbirth at home really would be the easier, less painful way to do it.

    ... And it was. Sacred and spiritual, just like you said.

    I think we as a society would be much better served to remember that giving birth is not a medical emergency but something our bodies were created to do. We are as strong as we think we are, and anyone who thinks, "OMG there's no way I'll be able to stand the pain!!!" is going to have a much worse time than someone who thinks, "Bring it ON!"

    As to why birth survival rates are better now than 150 years ago? I remember reading somewhere that it's actually tied to increased cleanliness in the hospitals, not so much the delivery methods practiced by doctors. (I mean, on your back in stirrups? SERIOUSLY? How about working WITH gravity instead of against it, people?)

    Thank goodness that someone with your reach is able to spread the message that birth doesn't have to be a pain-filled nightmare we can only face when we're numb to the eyeballs with drugs.

    I can't wait to read part II!

    07.13.09 - 04:18 PM
  • 153. Sinda said:

    I rarely comment here because OMG I don't know how you get through all of those comments, but you've got me here -

    Good for you! I'm so happy to hear that you were able to allow yourself to change your mind, and I love how wholeheartedly you did it - and how we never heard about it here.

    My 2nd birth was a total reaction to all of the wrong things the hospital did during #1 - I decided to take ownership of it, while for the first one I'd figured it would all work out. Well, I got an amazing child out of it, but a horrible experience. For #2, I did the Bradley method, and it's a treasured memory.

    Can't wait to hear the rest. Also, while I'm here, I love Marlo - her name, and her little self - she's perfection.

    07.13.09 - 04:18 PM
  • 154. fiona said:

    Ahh this story is making me so excited. So happy that you have had this amazing experience.

    I have two kids. Had two natural births. Both in hospitals but it's really supported here (Australia). I had easy recoveries. I was totally open to anything first time around, drugs if I needed them, didn't care. But I am so glad I had an amazing midwife and I could stay "sober". When pregnant the second time I was genuinely looking forward, yes you read that correctly, to experiencing birth again with my son.

    It's terrible how afraid of pain women are made to feel. It's GOOD pain not BAD pain. It's your body, doing what it knows how to do. You just need to get the hell out of your head and listen to your body.

    DAMMIT I sound like a dirty hippy. Ick.

    Can't wait to hear the rest of the story. Congratulations again.

    07.13.09 - 04:19 PM
  • 155. joy said:

    GOOD FOR YOU! I planned a natural birth for both--ended up with epidural with my first as it was a long labour. Managed without anything with the 2nd and it was amazing! Awful and painful but so empowering. Had both my babies in the UK and was allowed to make my own decisions about everything. We live in the US now and I'm so glad I'm finished having babies because having one here scares the heck out of me. So good to see a non-hippie advocating natural birth. Thank you.

    07.13.09 - 04:19 PM
  • 156. Anonymous said:

    I took a Bradley Method class and was 110 percent into the natural childbirth method too. The only thing I don't understand is how you did it w/o an epidural. PLEASE EXPLAIN.

    3 hours before my daughter was born, I gave in and asked for an epidural, because the pain was so horrendous, that I could not move. I was doubled over in pain, clammy, red, sweaty, trembling, could not control my breathing, could not concentrate.

    The last inning epidural was just what I needed to complete my natural childbirth. A friend of mine from my Bradley Method class did the same thing, and the epidural allowed her to get two hours sleep, wake up and push the baby right out.

    I do think most women get the epidural way to soon, and the medical interventions snowball.

    I am really looking forward to your part II. I want to know how you had control over yourself w/o an epidural. I tried the whole mind over matter, and it just did not work.

    07.13.09 - 04:20 PM
  • 157. Tracey said:

    In planning for my second child, I too found myself empowered by the idea of natural childbirth. I pored over every book on the subject, watched the Business of Being Born, researched doula etc. I was rallying against unnecessary medical interventions. I told my friends I'd never allow myself to be induced, that induction starts the downhill spiral of birth interventions.....ultimately resulting in a undesired c-section.

    And then, unexpectedly at 38 1/2 weeks, my baby died. Died in utero after a healthy and uneventful pregnancy. No answers as to why or how, she just died.

    And then all of a sudden, all of those thoughts of how we'd bring her into the world in a natural way seemed so shallow. What I wouldn't give to just have her here, and alive - any degree of medical intervention, if I could just have my baby live.

    She'd be 6 months old now, and I'd willingly take a c-section scar over this hole in my heart.

    07.13.09 - 04:25 PM
  • 158. Chriss said:

    Dude- you are much stronger then me if you made it through without drugs. I have three children I used some sort of drug each time. Much stronger. Good for you!

    07.13.09 - 04:25 PM
  • 159. Loretta said:

    Heather, I had a totally natural childbirth 29 years ago when I gave birth to my beautiful daughter. I walked into the hospital around 4 AM and, when I was finally checked by a nurse, found out that I was dilated to 10!!! I asked her what that meant (I still had to complete a few childbirth classes)and she told me that I could start "pushing". I was in pain so I asked for morphine (when in pain and in a hospital...you get morphine, right?) Well, she told me I could not have morphine or anything else!!! I thought that I was going to die right then and there. She helped me regulate the pushing with each contraction until I was able to push three times with every contraction. This went on for awhile until my husband said, "Whatever we're going to have has a lot of black hair"! I asked him how long he was able to see the head and he said, ...."fifteen minutes, or so". I excitedly told him to call the nurse who just happened to walk in and freaked out. She told me to stop pushing and she immediately wheeled me across to the delivery room. The doctor came in and said, "I'm going to give you a shot for the episiotomy but I'm afraid you're still going to feel it". I could feel the "tugging" as he cut but it was really nothing that hurt me. I asked if I could finally push and the doctor said, "Yes". After two pushes, my daughter came flying out. I asked if I could push out the afterbirth and I was told to "push away". The only medication I had since stepping foot into the hospital was a Tylenol because me tailbone hurt. The whole time I was in labor, I wasn't hooked up to anything...no fetal monitor, no IV's, nothing. I do remember feeling totally relaxed, calm and peaceful between contractions...a feeling I couldn't understand and a feeling I haven't had since. Looking back on the whole experience, I just thought that was the way every woman gave birth. Little did I know!!!!!!!!! My daughter gave birth 2 1/2 years ago to my grandson via c-section because he was in the breech position. She is going to have another baby in Oct. and she wants to try a VBAC. She has a great OB/GYN who will discuss that possibility as the time gets closer. She has heard my story a million times and she is hoping for a similar experience.

    07.13.09 - 04:25 PM
  • 160. Cate said:

    Thank you so much for writing this post. I realize medical intervention is sometimes necessary and I wouldn't deny that to anybody, but it's so ironic to me that women who won't have a sip of cola or an aspirin during their pregnancy are so willing to take absolutely anything to avoid any pain during the birth.

    The answer I have given to everyone who's asked me what childbirth is like is "It hurts and it's worth it."

    Let's hope you've inspired some women to try "natural".

    07.13.09 - 04:25 PM
  • 161. Gillian said:

    Effusive praise.

    My first was with a midwife in a hospital, drug-free kind of by accident actually. And it was absolutely a sacred and wonderful experience. Nobody believes me when I say that. Maybe they'll believe you. I remember the hard work more than the pain. I remember feeling like the badassedest badass in the world when I was done. I still do.

    Every one of my friends who was pregnant at the same time, including all the women in my hospital birthing class, TO A WOMAN, was induced early, got an epidural, the labor slowed down, and she had to have a C section. Every. Single. One. One had a scheduled C section because they were certain the baby was huge, and she'd never birth it without a third degree tear. The baby was seven pounds, perfectly average. One of them was induced because she had a mild uncomfortable rash and the doc said "Let's go ahead and get this baby out." 40 hours of labor with little progression, she had a C section, they nicked her without noticing, she passed out from massive internal bleeding, and two hours later she was sans uterus. 30 years old. One kid. Hysterectomy. For a mild rash.

    I love doctors, I do. I love hospitals. They mostly do wonderful work. But I hate the way pregnant, laboring, and delivering women are treated. Hate it. It is not a medical condition. It is a state of being that yes, may lead to increased chance of a medical condition. But pregnancy is not a disease to be cured.

    I'd better stop, before my horse gets so high I reach the stratosphere and pass out from lack of oxygen.

    07.13.09 - 04:26 PM
  • 162. kerry said:

    i'm glad you had such a great birthing experience. i wish i'd been able to have that with my two children.

    07.13.09 - 04:26 PM
  • 163. Jo said:

    I'm so excited to hear the rest of the story. I started out wanting to go the natural route and was able to do so with all three of my babies. Seeing as how I cry over hangnails...well...it was truly a miracle.

    I just loved The Business of Being Born. If someone is here and looking for inspiration then I also recommend Ina May Gaskin's book "Ina May's Guide to Childbirth". Also look into the Bradley Method. I swear, it will change your LIFE.

    :D

    07.13.09 - 04:29 PM
  • 164. shriek house said:

    Wow, this resonates for me so much (right up to and including the sprinkler tits) except with my 2nd delivery I chickened out again and demanded the epidural en route to the hospital. Reading your post makes me wish I'd summoned the huevos to do it naturally... and I'm so curious to hear how it went for you! Please don't keep us hanging too long.

    07.13.09 - 04:29 PM
  • 165. jojo44 said:

    After reading this amazing post, I know exactly why Heather manages to make a great living for her family through this blog. God Bless This Woman!! Seriously, you are incredible. This is the first comment I have every posted (because, who the hell is going to read it?).

    07.13.09 - 04:31 PM
  • 166. Katrin said:

    I wanted a natural childbirth when I had my first child. When the pain became unbearable, I begged for relief and my midwife, believing she was helping me keep my "promise" to myself, left me alone for an hour to think it over. I was in such pain I couldn't think. I knew then that if I were ever tortured it would take me less than two minutes to cave in.

    My child ended up weighing almost ten pounds and being turned the wrong way around. I pushed for three hours and when he came out, I tore all the way through. I couldn't have sex without pain for six months.

    The birth of my second child was like a miracle (apart from the absolute terror I felt until I got the epidural). I talked, laughed and participated in the birth. When she came out, I did not feel as though I had just been in a horrific car crash. I felt happy and exhausted and intact.

    I wish drug free childbirth had been something I could have loved and could have encouraged others to do. In theory, I do love it. In practice, it almost broke my spirit.

    I tell all first time mothers: Keep an open mind. Trust your instincts, either way.

    07.13.09 - 04:35 PM
  • 167. Robin said:

    I'm excited about this change in you!!And so so surprised to learn about this after hearing your views on vaccinations. Also love Marlo's name, my little guy's name is Milo. Can't wait for part 2!!

    07.13.09 - 04:37 PM
  • 168. Anonymous said:

    So glad you had this experience. SO GLAD. I wish you didn't have something against the hippies... because it's the hippies that know how eff'd up stuff's gonna get if we keep treating the earth and ourselves the way we are... but I'm REALLY glad that this particular light reached you. Like, stoked. Because people read you and love you... me included! And I only shave sometimes, and recycle everything, and cry about our atmosphere, and subscribe largely to a nature faith, and believe the disposable diapers are symbolic of our culture's shortsightedness and pain. But whatever. You rock and I wish the number of times I ping your site and read what you write would somehow fund your use and advocacy of sustainable stuff. But we can all dream, right?

    Best wishes with your beautiful little girls.

    07.13.09 - 04:37 PM
  • 169. Melissa H said:

    Thank you for writing this! I am pregnant with #2 and am already having nightmares about the delivery. Delivered #1 with no drugs and was fine but am already terrorized by what is ahead of me. I look forward to Part 2 (and maybe 3 and 4) to give me hope. And maybe I will go buy that book to remind myself why I want to do this au natural!

    07.13.09 - 04:38 PM
  • 170. Joceline said:

    I can't wait to read the rest of this story!

    I've had two natural births. The first was in a hospital, and the second was at home. Both were amazing in their own ways, but giving birth in my bathtub and being the very first one to pick my baby up, discover that she is a girl, and then hold her for two hours straight without interruption made me realize what a disservice the American medical system does to healthy moms and babies every day.

    I'm so glad you got to experience that incredible hormone rush and high after a natural birth! People look at me like I'm crazy when I try to describe it!

    07.13.09 - 04:42 PM
  • 171. Diana said:

    As one of those dirty hippies who births at home, I'd like to say congratulations. Every birth is amazing, no matter the small details but there's just something so fucking powerful in doing it naturally. You did good. Now, what's your address so I can send you your complimentary welcome to the club bottle of patchouli?

    07.13.09 - 04:45 PM
  • 172. Michelle said:

    I saw Business of Being Born after my daughter was born and was saddened again by my experience. I had been induced because I was ten days overdue, and everything I had read about induction happened to me, horrible, unnatural contractions, scary issues with my baby and all wrapped up in a c-section. The next time around I plan to empower myself and take control of the birth. I am looking forward to hearing part 2!

    07.13.09 - 04:46 PM
  • 173. Wendi said:

    My God, I don't know you, but you are NUTS and I love you!!

    07.13.09 - 04:46 PM
  • 174. Elizabeth Schroeder said:

    Heather, I'm sure that doulas everywhere can now see a jump in business, thanks to your mention. Can't wait for part two so we can see how everything went! I'm a labor doula and a midwifery student in Portland, OR and I am so appreciative of your willingness to think outside the box. Natural birth isn't for everyone, but it should at least be a viable alternative. And every woman giving birth in a hospital should be able to have a doula! Doulas can be a great source of support and encouragement, and numbers of women requiring cesareans and pain meds go way down with doulas. Thank you for this!

    07.13.09 - 04:46 PM
  • 175. Nancy Dunn said:

    Looking forward to reading the rest of your story. I'm currently trying to conceive but I already watched the documentary and read the book. I loved them both! I can't wait to be pregnant :)

    07.13.09 - 04:47 PM
  • 176. R. Wallis @ TrueBeauty said:

    Oh WOW! I can't wait for part two, this coming from someone so incredibly petrified of giving birth that I'm up for cutting me from toe to fingertip if necessary to just get the thing out without an episiotomy!!!
    All of you natural-birth mothers out there are liken to superwoman in my eyes. I'm such a wuss!

    07.13.09 - 04:48 PM
  • 177. Kris Bagiu Midwife said:

    I'm totally floored! When I first found your blog I read it from as far back as your archives go and read about the PPD you had with Leta and my first thought was: I hope she has a natural birth next time. I never imagined you'd do it! Or that you'd ever utter "home" and "birth" as a compound word ;) I'm thrilled you found a second to get riled up over a couple of paragraphs that changed your life. I've met Ricki Lake and Abby Epstein a few times now at events surrounding The Business of Being Born and can't thank them enough for the powerful service they are giving American women! Be sure and check out their website at http://mybestbirth.com/

    Kris, a midwife in Califorinia

    07.13.09 - 04:50 PM
  • 178. Julie said:

    I feel like I'm reading my birth story. I also wanted the drugs (this was my first pregnancy) but once I started doing research I discovered I didn't want any of that at all. And what really pissed me off was that when I went to my OB/GYN (who I had been seeing for years and knew it took us almost a year to get pregnant!) told me she didn't even deliver anymore! WTF? Why did she never tell me? Probably because some people would be ok with that. But I wasn't. I found a midwife (who rocks like there's no tomorrow!!!), hired a doula and took the Bradley class for 8 long weeks. And you know what?!...people thought I was crazy. I actually had someone tell me that I should get the drugs because when you go to the dentist you get drugs...and I'm like "you're equating birth to getting a cavity filled?" Anyways...I was fortunate that my labor went fast, my doula rocked and helped my husband (who does not like the sight of blood) stay calm, and my midwife delivered my little boy with no episiotomy and no drugs. I am proud of myself because I did the best for my little guy. I don't run around telling people I did it...but man am I proud!!!

    07.13.09 - 04:51 PM
  • 179. Cassidy Stockton said:

    Good for you! I haven't read the book, but did see The Business of Being Born and had much the same experience- that I couldn't believe how different we have made birth from the way it is supposed to be. Totally changed my worldview and I now feel confident that I will have a natural birth when that time comes. Way to go!!

    07.13.09 - 04:51 PM
  • 180. sneffnie said:

    I can't say that I understand any of this natural stuff but I can't wait to hear the rest of your story. :)

    07.13.09 - 04:52 PM
  • 181. Jennifer in PA said:

    Wow. I am shocked and impressed. Seriously. I'm sure you felt you could move mountains after the experience. I can't even imagine.

    I gave birth to my son (one and only child) 10 months ago and he was late, they had to induce (HORRIBLE!), it was back labor (AWFUL - epidural was a joke compared to the spinal pain) and they eventually had to go in with a vacuum to get him because I was low on amniotic fluid and he wasn't coming. And then the placenta broke up and they almost had to wheel me into surgery. It was truly an example of why we needed the hospital and specialists -- if we'd been at home without medical help nearby, neither he or I would have made it. HOWEVER, I do think our country totally opts for meds when we don't need to. If I didn't have so many complications, given that the epidural didn't do squat, I think I could see going natural.

    Someday we'll have baby #2 if we are so blessed and I'll give it serious thought. I'm just so scared of pain (I was screaming and crying and felt I was dying in delivery -- and that was WITH useless drugs), I'm not sure I can tough it out.

    Kudos to you, though, sister. Congratulations!

    07.13.09 - 04:52 PM
  • 182. KathyM said:

    Birthing my two kids naturally, drug-free, was the most powerful, painful and profound experience of my life. I'm so glad you got to experience that. Looking forward to the rest of the story :-)
    PS Heh, when I was doing the yelling duing labor it felt so primal--then, when I heard other women yelling later, I was all, oh, it just sounds like yelling... :-D
    PPS Love the new masthead

    07.13.09 - 04:53 PM
  • 183. Erin said:

    Yay Heather!

    I am six months pregnant with my first, and I just read that book - it must be the 8th or 9th preggo book I've read, but I really, really liked it and it did really make sense out of it all without being overly preachy or nutso. I went out and got myself a doula about a month ago, because I'm not sure my fiance is going to know what to do when I start yelling and screaming at everybody.

    I'm stoked to read part two of the birth story!

    07.13.09 - 04:53 PM
  • 184. Ashley said:

    I don't really ever leave comments, I figure you've had enough comments to last you many, many lifetimes, but I wanted to second the suggestion of reading Misconceptions by Naomi Wolf. I'm fairly sure you will like it, it seems in the same vein as the Ricki Lake book you mentioned.

    07.13.09 - 04:54 PM
  • 185. V. said:

    Congratulations, Heather!

    Ricki Lake may not know it but she owes an enormous debt to Ina May Gaskin, who championed the un-drugged birth back in the 1970s. Her book, "Spiritual Midwifery", filled with first-person birth stories, will knock your socks off. www.inamay.com/

    07.13.09 - 04:54 PM
  • 186. Jill Pilgrim said:

    I LOVED that documentary! I can't wait to read the rest of your labor story.

    07.13.09 - 04:54 PM
  • 187. Sherri said:

    Dude...You're great! I can't wait for part 2, 3, however many it takes...what a TEASE this was!!! I'm happy for you! I went through the All Natural birth with my first, my Son. I am now Pregnant again 5 years later, and have the same goal. I know the pain, and I know the inevitable amazement that comes for so long afterwards. I never felt more like a Woman; although I can't say I would have felt any less so the other route, because that's something I haven't experienced. I'm glad you got your wish of natural labor!

    07.13.09 - 04:55 PM
  • 188. Meredith said:

    Yeah, no. I am due in January and labor scares the HELL out of me! I have already told my doctor to have an epidural on hand cause I will need it! Plus, I am scared to death about a c-section. Let's just hope that doesn't happen. It may send me into convulsions.

    ~Meredith

    07.13.09 - 04:58 PM
  • 189. Jamie said:

    Thank you for the book recommendation! "Your Best Birth" has been purchased! I am at 15 weeks in my first pregnancy, and have always dreamed of minimizing the effect modern medicine would have on my birthing experience. Water birth interests me, as does doing things drug-free. My main reason for wanting to be drug free is to be able to push like they will tell me to! But also, I want to be "present" for the whole thing. I figure, if women dating back to the dark ages did it naturally, I certainly can. I really look forward to hearing the rest of your labor story, just as I do each and every post of yours.

    Thank you for keeping Internet so closely involved in your life! I heart you!!

    07.13.09 - 05:00 PM
  • 190. Sarah said:

    I've never commented before, but I just had to say that I had a very similar experience to you...only without being pregnant. I've always scoffed at the notion of home births but I randomly came across the Business of Being Born at 9:00 on a Sunday night and like you, it changed my life. I feel so ridiculously naive for not even taking the time to do the research on this subject. I am not pregnant yet but plan to be in the next few years (hopefully) and I'm so glad I have that time to do the research. Your story gives me hope and is so encouraging.

    07.13.09 - 05:02 PM
  • 191. Michelle said:

    Home birthing/ hypno birthing nutso here, applauding and squealing with delight!

    07.13.09 - 05:03 PM
  • 192. Stephanie said:

    I am so not good with pain so I'm really excited about reading about how it all went. I'm definitely the one that would be right there with you on the epidural on the rocks, but knowing that that was you, makes me wonder if I could do this too. When I'm thinking about kids, I'll definitely be checking out the book and movie you recommended.

    07.13.09 - 05:04 PM
  • 193. The Mom Claire said:

    I really wanted a natural birth and to breast feed and to use cloth diapers and to be a stay at home mom but nothing worked like I wanted it to and I am fine with it. I have a healthy happy 4 year old daughter. Now with baby #2 (that is still in the thinking phase), I will still want a natural birth and to breast feed.. I have given up on cloth diapers and being a stay at home mom... two out of three aint bad!
    I so wanted a nautral birth but after hearing my mom scream for 3 hours WHILE I WAS IN LABOR that I had no clue the pain I was about to experience I just went ahead and got the damn thing so that she would shut up! Breast feeding would have been a breeze if my sweet little baby was not intolorant of breast milk... it just all went down hill after that!
    But here I am with a happy health 4 year old and a mom that still yells that I have no clue... I wonder if they make epidurals that shut her up?? Worth looking into if you ask me!

    07.13.09 - 05:07 PM
  • 194. Candice said:

    Wow, I am REALLY intrigued to read the rest of your post and give that book a look because I, too, have viewed it skeptically and hope to get some painkillers two days before I'm due.

    07.13.09 - 05:08 PM
  • 195. Robin said:

    I had truly nightmare birth experiences for all 3 of my children. The first was full term stillborn. All three had HIGHLY encouraged epidurals, none of which did anything for pain but slowed my labors to nothing. My second child was in distress and the doctor, also in distress over the threat of another stillbirth yelled at me during my first push to "not be a wussy and push that baby out". They actually kicked my husband out of the room during my third while they tried to convince me that it would work this time. They then apologized to him outside of the room for the epidural not working once again as well as my turtle on the back status due to what they had done for the remainder of the labor. I want more kids and I absolutely crave a decent if not good birth experience. I suppose it is right to be grateful for two healthy out of three right? I am so glad to hear it was a great moment in your life. It is very encouraging and inspiring.

    07.13.09 - 05:08 PM
  • 196. rosanna said:

    Yay Heather!!

    I had my baby in May and also did it all natural. I'm the biggest baby when it comes to pain, seriously. The other day when I asked my husband to rip off my band-aid, I was shaking! But learning about how unnecessary medical interventions have a greater chance of leading to c-sections sealed the deal for me.

    I had a wonderful birth experience!!
    (you can read about it here: http://mattrosanna.blogspot.com/2009/05/fins-birth-story-as-told-by-mama... )

    07.13.09 - 05:10 PM
  • 197. Kat said:

    And this, Ms. Dooce, is why I love you. :) Looking forward to the next part.

    07.13.09 - 05:12 PM
  • 198. L. said:

    Heather, to be honest, I couldn't believe your doctor offered to induce Leta because he was going on vacation (if I remember correctly). But that sort of thing is sadly common. I believe our society's cavalier attitude toward interventions has led to a high C-section rate and to other problems that are harder to see--more difficulty breastfeeding, maybe more PPD, etc.

    However, though I did two natural water births in the hospital I would never do a home birth, precisely because things can go wrong so very quickly. One of the most exciting things about birth in the U.S. in recent years is the conjunction of the medical and wholistic--hospitals are starting to offer birthing centers, practitioners are seeing the benefits of natural births and becoming comfortable with doulas, etc.

    I'm so glad you had that serendipitous encounter with Lake's book. After my first birth I felt like I was high for MONTHS and I think it was something to do with it being natural. (Just had a second a week or two before you, it wasn't quite as fabulous, but heck, it's good for the baby too.)

    Congratulations again. Marlo is GORGEOUS. The most beautiful baby I've ever seen, honestly--except mine, of course :)

    07.13.09 - 05:12 PM
  • 199. steph said:

    I too had a homebirth with my first (now 11) and natural childbirth with my second at a birth center (no pain meds available even if I wanted them).

    The homebirth was so un-effing-believably painful, at one point I literally tried to leave my body and squeeze into the the point in the high part of the wall where the cieling and the two walls all meet....that little point. I was certain I was going to split in half and die. I had 7 hours of hard labor, exploded my son out and then realized I still had to birth the placenta! I cried. No more. I truly believe I had post traumatic stress syndrome from the pain. HOWEVER, I am so glad I did it. I read many books on natural birth, attended natural childbirth classes, had a midwife, a doula and Husband. One book I read said the birth would be orgasmic! HAHAHAHAHAHAAAAHAHAHA. Not. A. Chance.

    My daughter came in 1 hour, pain intense, but much faster. Thank the sweet ass lord.

    07.13.09 - 05:13 PM
  • 200. Vanessa said:

    So here I sit, a week and a half away from my due date with baby boy number two and I'm hoping for a second home birth. I myself was a home birth baby (my Momma was a rebel!) but I'm pretty much the opposite of a hippie. I scoff at hippies and my husband and I make fun of them, but gosh! My first experience was labouring and giving birth at home and I wouldn't have had it any other way.
    We've had to work around a few obstacles this time around, but I'm still hoping for a home birth or if I have to go to the hospital to avoid all drugs.
    I had no idea this post was coming and I'm now eagerly anticipating part two!
    I also heard about this documentary recently and am hoping to watch it soon.

    07.13.09 - 05:14 PM
  • 201. Margi said:

    I'm so happy that you had such a great labor and birth. I know what you're saying about having a natural childbirth being such a great experience. I have 5 children, and had epidurals with the first and the last 2. I had the 2nd and 3rd natural. The only thing I would say is that I am just glad they are all here and all healthy.

    As much as we think we can plan these things, really so many things can go wrong, or change and nothing works out the way you wanted it to. I have had too many friends and family members who have bought into the whole "natural is better", who have had to go another route, and then felt like failures for not having been able to stick to their plan. That is my only issue. I'm happy I experienced both. At the end of my nine months, nobody gave me a gold star for having a natural birth, I had beautiful babies every time.

    07.13.09 - 05:15 PM
  • 202. KRIstin kaminski said:

    I just LOVE you! Even READING the word "doula" made my eyes roll. But I SO want to read that book!! And I'm not even dating anyone let alone planning kids. And I Detest smug anything...hippies or religious zealots...all the same. But I also detest corporate America...so this should be interesting!
    CONGRATULATIONS :)

    07.13.09 - 05:15 PM
  • 203. Dani said:

    Wow more power to ya. Personally I was total happy with the drugs and my c-section. Of coarse my daughter was atempting to come out butt first and I just thought trying to fold her like a taco and push her out my girlie parts didn't sound like a good idea. But then I got the experience I wanted which I think is the important thing for most Moms. I say healthy kid & healthy mom however you get there is up to you.

    07.13.09 - 05:18 PM
  • 204. Jennifer said:

    If your part two says that you had a beautiful and natural childbirth I'm going to have to hate you. At least for a minute. That's SO what I wanted. And when I said I wanted to go drug free, EVERYONE, including my doctor discouraged it. In the end, it was probably better that I had changed my mind and decided to get the epidural. I had to have an emergency c-section. So it saved them some time with getting me ready.

    07.13.09 - 05:19 PM
  • 205. Cory said:

    You better continue this soon because I just cannot believe it!! Childbirth HURTS LIKE HELL and there's no way I could've done it without an epi. My contractions didn't come and go. Labor was ONE LONG CONTRACTION for me. There's no way I could've survived that naturally. Looking forward to hearing how you did it. Congratulations girl - wish you lived in NYC.

    07.13.09 - 05:19 PM
  • 206. Jessica said:

    Ah, I cant' wait for part 2!! I've gotten goosebumps every time you talk about your birth experience so far, so I've been wondering WHAT happened!
    I know my husband was thrilled to have a doula with us after he figured out that she would/could do anything he deemed 'icky' (which is about everything, lol). I'd love to hear your husbands version after we read yours!
    Yeah yeah yeah!
    And hey, there have been a lot of us midwife, natural birth, homebirth loving so-called-crazy people that have been posting HINTS here too!!!!!

    I'm so glad you got from that book a spark that gave you information. THAT's the main goal those 'crazy' radicals have-- give women (and parents) information so we can make our own damn decisions!!!!

    I still can't write my birth stories (the not-so-amazing one and the amazing empowering natural (hospital) birth and it has been 5 and 2 years. I get angry every time I start because of what I didn't get with my son, and that not everyone is offered the amazing birth like my daughters. Someday I'll write them....
    In the meantime I LOVE to read empowering birth stories and try to find ways to calmly and respectfully encourage women to seek out information.
    I've been wanting to reply to several of your recent posts (Hugs for mastitis, go you for your beautiful baby and birth, kudos for breastfeeding and keeping the ppd at bay, etc etc) but this one I HAVE to respond to... even with my little one crawling all over me(-;
    Jessica

    07.13.09 - 05:21 PM
  • 207. Natballs said:

    I'm due in 5 weeks... terrible nervous, although I'm not having an at home birth.

    07.13.09 - 05:22 PM
  • 208. lisa mertins said:

    i can't wait to read whether there was pitocin - a drug invented by dick cheney before he got into gov'mint. cause the pitocin is not a friend of natural childbirth like the bush admin was not a friend to democracy...

    07.13.09 - 05:23 PM
  • 209. Another Heather said:

    HOT DAMN, Heather! I'm sitting here waiting for these contractions to become more regular and LOVE LOVE LOVING your timimg! Kudos on the natural birth and having your sense of humor intact wayyyyy before the lady parts have stopped hurting.

    And in the name of all that is sacred -

    PLEASE BRING US PARTS TWO - TWELVE before I have this baby! I've already done my Ina May and Ricki Lake homework and know the DOOCE-account-of-natural-birth is going to be WAY more useful to me!

    07.13.09 - 05:26 PM
  • 210. Parsing Nonsense said:

    Oh my goodness, I'm so excited you're writing about this! I, too, saw "The Business of Being Born" and it shifted my worldview as well. I've never been pregnant before, but suddenly I found a confidence in my ability to bear children I'd never had.

    I can't wait for the second installation! Maybe next you can tell us how you recovered from mastitis while still breastfeeding. After a natural childbirth, do you no longer feel any pain?

    07.13.09 - 05:27 PM
  • 211. Catherine said:

    Wow! That was so exciting and wonderful for me to read. I am just a college student, never been pregnant or given birth, but after a class on Women's Health that covered the issues surrounding pregnancy and childbirth I've become fascinated with natural birth and hope to somehow pursue a career in it. I'm planning on training to be a doula in the near future. But then, when considering my own childbirth sometime in the distant future, and considering how bad I am with pain.... worried me! Your story is inspiring!

    07.13.09 - 05:27 PM
  • 212. mdog said:

    I had never heard anyone say they could feel their milk "drop" or "come in" before I read your blog. I'm so confused - isn't the milk already always in your boobs? Or does it shoot into your "top area" from some mysterious, milk-making gland that I don't know about?

    I'm not a mom, so I'm just so curious and baffled by this process.

    07.13.09 - 05:27 PM
  • 213. Maria said:

    Isn't it great?! Never in your wildest dreams did you think you could ever do it and here you are! I had my son (almost 21 years ago) with lots of pitocin, IVs, etc. I vowed to never do that again. My 2 girls (16 and 11) were both born with no anesthesia and they were the most wonderful experiences of my life. I am totally enjoying hearing about your journey. Keep up the good work! You have a beautiful family. :-)

    07.13.09 - 05:27 PM
  • 214. Jennifer said:

    Bravo to you, Heather! I saw "The Business of Being Born" when I was about 5-6 months pregnant, and went into absolute hysterics (I watched it by myself while my husband was out of town -- bad move) knowing the kind of medicalized birth my hospital was known to encourage. I ended up meticulously developing a birth plan with my doctors and nurses for a natural birth, and ended up with pitocin, blood pressure medication, an epidural, and... an emergency c-section! Next time around I will definitely employ the help of a doula and a birthing center to get the natural birth I was hoping for.

    Thanks for sharing your story!

    07.13.09 - 05:27 PM
  • 215. Amanda said:

    Heather...I am so damn proud of you.

    "The Business of Being Born", really helped me through a very difficult time. After planning to have a natural birth with my first child...after MANY hours of natural labor....midwives and doulas out of the wazoo.... a c-section was the outcome, and it was NOT an easy psychological or emotional recovery for me....
    this documentary reaffirmed my choices...and it empowered my decision to go for the VBAC (I have 8 weeks to go!!!)
    However, the documentary also helped me come to terms with the fact that some babies are just meant to be born in ways that are outside of our ideal plans...which for me initially was a very hard pill to swallow.

    I am SO GRATEFUL that Marlo's birth was empowering for you...
    and that you were able to explore your options...
    bravo!

    07.13.09 - 05:28 PM
  • 216. Mirinda said:

    Had 3 natural births and loved it. Well, it hurt like hell but was so worth it. Dropped my OBGYN at 32 weeks with my first cause she LAUGHED when she read my birth plan that did not include an epidural. I'm not one of these judgy women who think it's horrible women have epidurals. But it's also something that can be done and, I believe, is better for you and the baby. So congrats :)

    Also? Had a doula with all 3 as well. Couldn't even tell you if my husband was in the room with any of them. LOVE that woman!

    07.13.09 - 05:29 PM
  • 217. Kim said:

    Awesome!!!! I had both of my boys natural and I loved it. I even did it 15 years ago when it wasn't even cool and hip. Because of you, it will become even more cool and hip.

    07.13.09 - 05:29 PM
  • 218. Anonymous said:

    Great. And here I had full intentions of having an epidural for the first time when I give birth to my 5th child in Dec. Now I'm going to have to go read that book and change my mind. Thanks a LOT.

    07.13.09 - 05:32 PM
  • 219. Anonymous said:

    I'm so thrilled to see natural birth get a moment to shine in the spotlight with your writing. The more it gets discussed the better! Maybe someday HMO's will pay for home births and maternity leave will be paid (Har har).
    Congratulations for discovering how strong you are.

    I'd high five you but I'm sure your hands are full.

    07.13.09 - 05:32 PM
  • 220. Brandy S said:

    I am excited to hear the rest of the story. I had an epidural for both of my pregnancies and I am excited to hear from some one who did it both ways. I do believe what I did, pushing a baby out of my vagina, was natural (with or with out drugs). It just bothers me that people call it natural w/out "drugs" and I guess unnatural with out? Anyway can't hear the rest.

    07.13.09 - 05:33 PM
  • 221. Mary said:

    I'm another one who planned on having drugs but then sat at home too long, in denial (I completely seriously tried to convince my husband that I wasn't in labor-- it must be a stomach bug-- the day after my due date) and got to the hospital too far along to have drugs and too far along for them even to put an IV in my arm. Score! I moaned and groaned and screamed and swore and in the end is was The Best Thing Ever.

    I can't wait to hear the rest of your story!

    07.13.09 - 05:33 PM
  • 222. Seshat said:

    I applaud your courage. Epidurals were helpful to me, especially with my first child. I had four baby girls ranging from 9 lb. 3 oz. to 10 lb. 3 oz. I was so stressed and out of it for the first, it couldn't have been good for my daughter. All but one were also posterior. Obviously, you had a good result..she's adorable...they are adorable; I look forward to the rest of the story, and let's all be open minded and support each other. Those who didn't choose this route shouldn't feel a sense of regret. Each situation is so very individual. Despite epidurals, all four of them were very alert, active, and were nursing immediately.

    07.13.09 - 05:35 PM
  • 223. Dayna said:

    Well I had a nice long comment typed out and then it disappeared. Ahh!

    I had two pregnancies and two miscarriages. Each time I had planned for the wonderful drugs. Got pregnant a third time, "educated" myself online and with books and found those very interesting statistics you don't hear about at the docs office and decided intervention-free was the way for me...as long as all was going smoothly.

    Hired a doula (who was awesome and took great pics too). Found a midwife practice that I loved. Had a 4-hour whirlwind labor start to finish and gave birth at the hospital in the water (they have two birthing suites set up for waterbirths) to a 8lb 15oz girl who was beautiful! THE most painful experience of my life while at the same time THE most powerful and moving experience I could have ever imagined.

    A woman's birth should go exactly how she wants it to go (as long as baby is safe of course), not at the convenience of her provider. Having a birthplan that you are clear about with your doc/midwife can go a long way to getting what you want. Of course, always be ready for the unexpected too and don't be disappointed if your natural birth doesn't work out. The final goal is always going to be the same thing, a healthy baby and that is what makes it all worthwhile. Keep an open mind. That's all from my soapbox.

    Best part...I didn't even have to get an IV...huge relief to me because I am TERRIFIED of needles! =)

    07.13.09 - 05:35 PM
  • 224. Amy said:

    Just thought I comment for the first time to mention.... in Canada at least, the midwives have full hospital support and privileges. I gave birth in December to my beautiful Charlie, supported by my midwives, IN THE HOSPITAL- which was my birth plan. It is truly the best of both worlds. My delivery room door stayed closed to any medical personel except my midwives until I needed them, and when I did, (after completing my whole labour and 2.5 hours of pushing with no meds), the OB/GYN Chief came in to help me and my horribly stuck and now distressed baby. I am a huge fan of natural birth and I support home birth. I just knew that home birth wasn't in *my* comfort zone- my intuition told me no to home birth. Instead, I had a lovely experience with my midwives, and knew that others were standing by if I needed them.... and I did- on top of the stuck and distressed baby- I hemorraged. I'm proud of my birth plan.

    Heather- good for you! Midwives are amazing, and for those who are convinced, but need to quell some fears... midwives in the hospital may work for you.

    07.13.09 - 05:38 PM
  • 225. the niffer said:

    Ooo the suspense! I'm dying! I had a similar epiphany after reading "The Thinking Woman's Guide to a Better Birth". The title pissed me off, so I read it and went all natural and granola. Can't wait to do it again in November.

    07.13.09 - 05:40 PM
  • 226. Jan said:

    How cool! I just watched the documentary last weekend and also found it perfectly logical and very compelling. I'm 63, so it's not for me, but good for you! Watching the film, I was struck by how peaceful it was, and how intimate. Way to go!!

    07.13.09 - 05:40 PM
  • 227. Lynnie said:

    Good for you, Heather!

    I'm amazed by how each birth experience is so unique. While living in Oregon in 1977, I signed up with a birth center which had midwives, a nutritionist, birthing classes, a library, and a little house where the family could be during the birthing process. The doctor was on the phone and the hospital nearby, if needed.

    I had been in prodromal labor at home for a couple of days, with contractions out of sinc. My midwife told me to drink an ounce of vodka to get my system in line for a productive labor, and not to worry, this would not affect the baby. It worked! Once at the birth home, my labor progressed, but baby was in a posterior position with his forehead pushing on my pubic bone. My midwives told me to try doing pelvic rocks on my hands and knees to help turn the baby. It worked, too!

    These knowledgeable and patient women most certainly saved me from the trauma of a C-section, and provided the most calm and caring environment in which to bring the newest member of our family into the world. Unfortunately, modern medicine has frightened us so much that many mothers-to-be have given up making their birth experiences personal and special.

    Looking back, that time was the best bonding experience for our entire family. It gave me such a connection with my peaceful baby, self-assurance about the wisdom of my own body, and gratitude for a community that understood the need for a safe birthing alternative.

    Thank you for sharing your epiphany and subsequent inner guidance with us. (and no, I've never worn patchouli oil!)

    07.13.09 - 05:42 PM
  • 228. Laura said:

    I had home births. When child #3 was born #2 climbed in the bed (after everything was cleaned up) and read to the baby. It was the sweetest thing. We also ordered pizza. Maybe the birth wasn't spiritual but it made for good memories.

    I am imagining Coco at a home birth.

    07.13.09 - 05:42 PM
  • 229. Sara JOY said:

    Dooce,

    SO SO SO incredibly happy for you. A note/reality check though - natural birth doesn't always go how you plan, or want it to go, just like everything else. Labor is different for everyone, and sometimes can't be managed the way we would like.
    I have a ridiculously high pain tolerance, and my family and husband keep telling me I am the toughest person they know. I planned like you did, massive reasearch and 40 hours of education in a class. My 23 hours of labor were the most horrifying moments of my life, second only to the death of my son 4 days later because he was breech and his head got trapped. He suffered a lack of oxygen and never breathed without a ventilator. We had to choose to remove life support, there is nothing worse in this world.
    I know that I am the one in a million TERRIBLE homebirth stories. I believe in natural birth and homebirth, but folks, things aren't as rosy as the natural birth advocates would like you to think. You can be traumatized by a natural birth just the same as a medicalized birth. And studies...well, there are always two sides...
    Sorry to be Debbie Downer, but I am still so raw I couldn't let this go.
    Again - SO happy for you Dooce, really. :D
    Sara Joy

    07.13.09 - 05:43 PM
  • 230. Mari said:

    When I was pregnant with my first child, a friend gave me an old book "Childbirth Without Fear". It changed my life, I'm sure my birthplan would have been much different and unnatural without it. I'm glad you had such a great experience!

    07.13.09 - 05:44 PM
  • 231. Shnerfle said:

    #1. I LOVE the new masthead. LOVE.
    #2. You are so much braver (by which I mean crazier) than I am. My epidural WAS on the rocks. With a narcotic chaser. I'd tell you the name of it, but it's all kinda fuzzy now. While I don't regret the epidural (in fact, I miss it), the painkillers left their mark not only on my memory, but on my son. I think they made it harder on us both.
    #3 I can't WAIT to hear what the waitress at Outback said!

    07.13.09 - 05:45 PM
  • 232. Kate said:

    I love that the book and movie were done by Rikki Lake because she sits there in her fancy New York clothes and swills her Starbucks and chats with her girlfriend about the miracle of natural childbirth. It's great because she is so not a hippie, but she gets it that birth doesn't have to be awful and terrible. I am so glad that you had such a wonderful birth experience with Marlo. She's a lovely baby.

    07.13.09 - 05:46 PM
  • 233. Sunny said:

    Let me just say i squealed out loud with joy when I read this. And then MY milk let down, LOL!!

    I had an unassisted homebirth (planned) with my second, after a very disappointing hospital birth with my first. It was the most incredible experience of my life and I'd do it again in a heartbeat. My husband--who caught--agrees 100%. Many of the problems my oldest had in labor and after birth were CAUSED by the hospital setting and staff. My second had no issues, and while I hemorrhaged after his birth, it was nothing we weren't prepared to handle :)

    07.13.09 - 05:46 PM
  • 234. Anonymous said:

    I'm so excited to hear about your birth experience. I've never given birth before, but am trying to become pregnant right now, and have been researching pregnancy and delivery.

    I'm not sure how, but I stumbled upon the documentary by Ricki Lake a few months ago, and was transformed about how I thought about labor and delivery. My friends are getting tired of me talking about it. When I saw she had written a book, I read it in one sitting. I agree, both should be read by every pregnant women, actually every women for that matter.

    I'm so glad you're writing about natural child birth. I feel like a change is coming in America, and its great that such a popular blogger, such as yourself, is writing about the subject.

    I can only hope the discussion is wrapped around women's choices in childbirth, and not a divisive battle between proponents of each side. Every childbirth method that ends with a healthy baby and mother is a good method, but a lot of women don't realize they have more choices than just epidural or no epidural.

    Thanks Heather, and congrats on your beautiful baby!

    07.13.09 - 05:47 PM
  • 235. victoria winters said:

    I just watched that film last week and it got me thinking that it would be a great idea for the second. But how on earth do you get through that knife in the cervix pain? I thought I was going to die. BUT, I did make it all the way to 7cm before getting the epidural, so I probably could have done it...couldn't I? Eek! Good thing number 2 is still only a thought.

    07.13.09 - 05:50 PM
  • 236. Jen said:

    Good for you Heather! I had an epidural-free hospital birth 5 months ago and would love to have a home birth for baby #2. The Business of Being Born is an amazing documentary. I've emailed Oprah to have her do a show on it, but alas... Maybe now that you're a fan of TBOBB, she'll listen up!

    Hang in there with the mastitis. I had that as well as thrush and nipple vasospasms. Breastfeeding is harder than childbirth, hands (and boobs) down. Keep it up though because it will pass...

    07.13.09 - 05:51 PM
  • 237. mountainmomma18 said:

    That is a great book. I had a pain-med free childbirth, but not by choice. My epidural worked for about 2 hours, then it didn't. i bought this book because I did not want to be unprepared the next time. I was walloped the first time, I thought i would have this magical experience with lots of drugs, instead I yelled at the doctor to pull my daughter out when he saw her head cause I was tired of pushing.

    07.13.09 - 05:53 PM
  • 238. Kate said:

    Very much looking forward to reading the rest of your story, as I've been considering an unmedicated birth since I had my daughter via a forceps delivery that resulted in a giant episiotomy that prevented me from sitting down for six entire weeks. My recovery was so painful that I started reading more about unmedicated births and it seems that gee, if I hadn't gotten the epidural maybe I could have pushed better and then I wouldn't have needed the forceps that required the giant episiotomy that had me nursing my baby standing up for six miserable heavily medicated weeks.

    Anyway, can't wait to hear *your* story!

    07.13.09 - 05:56 PM
  • 239. desiree fawn said:

    I totally had a homebirth. No drugs, no meds, nothing.

    It was the most painful and intense experience I've ever been through and I would do it again TOMORROW if you asked me to.

    I will have all my kids at home (well, both.. all three? who knows).

    I just loved it!!

    ps. congrats again -- she's just so damn cute!

    07.13.09 - 05:56 PM
  • 240. Tricia said:

    I had an eerily similar experience...a hefty epidural the first time, and a totally out of character decision to go natural the second time around. An amazing accomplishment in this day and place. Congrats on your natural birth, I look forward to reading more about it!

    07.13.09 - 05:57 PM
  • 241. muttlery & catlery said:

    Oh Heather!! I hear you! My first was a c-section and I thought the doctors had SAVED MY BABY'S LIFE. Next pregnancy I found out that I had, in fact, become a statistic of a mismanaged labour and an overly medicalised attitude to birth. My next two labours were vaginal (I had to fight so hard against doctors not to have csections because I had already had one) and I too read everything I could and armed myself with a doula (independent midwife here in Australia). My advice to anyone having their first baby is to not just believe what the doctors tell you and GET AN INDEPENDENT MIDWIFE. They know far more than doctors about LABOUR and they will know if you need medical intervention - at which stage the medical expertise of a doctor is more than welcome. I look forward to your next installment....I imagine you have had a very empowering experience. Much love!!!!

    07.13.09 - 05:57 PM
  • 242. em said:

    I can't wait to hear the rest!
    I really, really, really wanted a natural birth. I did a whole lot of preparation, but after the 48 hour "emergency" induction with a whole lotta unwanted, but necessary pitocin, I just needed that stupid epidural. I hope it all worked out for you.

    07.13.09 - 05:58 PM
  • 243. Anonymous said:

    I use to think the same way and when I watched business of being born omg! that really put thing into the light..awesome documentary and I can't wait to read that book. looking fwd to part 2.

    07.13.09 - 05:59 PM
  • 244. Kelley said:

    I'm so glad you enjoyed Ricki Lake's book and documentary and doubly glad your birthing experience was so positive and memorable for you. As an Ob-Gyn, I found the documentary extremely one sided and biased against doctors. ALL deliveries are not medicinized. Obstetricians are not the anti-Christ; we save a lot of moms and babies. We want healthy moms and babies too, and sometimes that calls for medicine. What I remember most from the movie is this: Abby in the diner saying how small her belly was. Abby's midwife not confirming fetal presentation while she was in labor and allowing her to labor with a breech infant. The emergent cesarean delivery she underwent of her growth restricted baby. An obstetrician might have caught the growth restriction and the breech earlier. That's all. Congrats on Marlo again.

    07.13.09 - 06:01 PM
  • 245. Anonymous said:

    Now I kind of feel like a dick for not wanting natural childbirth.

    07.13.09 - 06:01 PM
  • 246. Em Komiskey said:

    I'm so happy that you're posting this. I am looking forward to Part II. I loved the birth of my daughter, and I will agree that a natural childbirth is absolutely a spiritual experience. There was some pain, sure, but it was far outweighed by the feeling of empowerment, the intensity and the sheer sense of joy that came out of me with that tiny life. It was just a bonus that I got to prove wrong all the people who thought I was crazy for wanting a natural childbirth.

    07.13.09 - 06:02 PM
  • 247. Anonymous said:

    I watched that documentary and all it made me feel was guilt.

    07.13.09 - 06:03 PM
  • 248. delilah said:

    I had a natural birth with all three of my children. My only reason was that I didn't want to have nausea when they handed me my beautiful baby (pain meds make me vomit!!!) and it was the best decision every made. All of my nurses said my deliveries were some of the best births they participated in and it was an honor to be with our family. Birth is hard, but when it is over, it is over and the pain is gone. Preparedness is the key....obviously you had the golden key!!!

    07.13.09 - 06:04 PM
  • 249. Rose said:

    Rock on, Heather! I had a homebirth with my first and it was amazing!

    Can't wait to read the rest!

    07.13.09 - 06:08 PM
  • 250. Meara said:

    I had my second child without any drugs, largely because he arrived in such an all-fired hurry....I was just grateful I was on a gurney in the ER and not in the front seat of our family car!
    BUT...for the third child, I opted for natural birth, and am so grateful. p.s. she was 9 lbs., 13 oz. Recovery was such a breeze in comparison to the cutting and pasting in the firstborn's delivery...and it was indeed very spiritual.
    Thanks for sharing your story!

    07.13.09 - 06:10 PM
  • 251. Anonymous said:

    Holy shit, Heather! Way to go!

    07.13.09 - 06:11 PM
  • 252. ladyelms said:

    from another homebirth nutso--thank you and welcome to the other side. and look, you made it w/o smelling like patchouli. :)

    07.13.09 - 06:12 PM
  • 253. Ashley B. said:

    Thank you so much for this post! My husband and I are trying to conceive and right after we started I stumbled upon Ricki Lake's movie. I agree with you IT CHANGED MY LIFE. I'm not pregnant yet, but it set my philosophy for pregnancy whenever it happens. I'm now consumed with natural birth information. Thanks for sharing your story with us! Can't wait to hear the rest.

    07.13.09 - 06:14 PM
  • 254. ladyelms said:

    from another homebirth nutso--thank you and welcome to the other side. and look, you made it w/o smelling like patchouli. :)

    07.13.09 - 06:14 PM
  • 255. Anonymous said:

    You are my woman! =) I love how this story started - you sound like me, haha. I had my baby on the 19th of June and had a 15 hour labor naturally. Two and a half hours of pushing! It was AMAZING. I am a total natural child birth fan now, and encourage EVERYONE to try it! Obviously if you NEED the interventions, they can save your life, but the majority of women DON'T! =) Congrats!

    07.13.09 - 06:14 PM
  • 256. Other Bridget said:

    I didn't really like The Business of Being Born but if that's what it took to get you an awesome birth experience, great. For me, it was the book Birth by Tina Cassidy. Changed my life and made it possible for me to consider going through labor for a second child (my first one was induced and high-intervention, juuuuust this side of a C-section).

    The birth of my second child - drug and IV-free - was the greatest thing I'll ever accomplish. Birth story here.

    07.13.09 - 06:15 PM
  • 257. Erin said:

    WELL FUCK ME!
    I never ever ever thought this is the direction your birth story would head.

    How AWESOME!
    You are AWESOME!
    AWESOMENESS! Here, have a cookie.
    Can't wait to read the rest.

    (Also my Input Format Commenty thing is "now kones" and i'm like, don't mind if i do. Maybe y'all dont konw what a "cone" is and now i just seem crazy and unstable. Goddamn New Zealand upbringing leaving me unprepared for communicating with Americans)

    (PS: have been reading your blog for approximatly ever and this is the first time i've commented. yay)

    07.13.09 - 06:17 PM
  • 258. ellen said:

    Ricki Lake? As in..."Hairspray" Ricki Lake? I'm having trouble getting past that.

    07.13.09 - 06:17 PM
  • 259. Katharine said:

    Congratulations, Heather!

    I had an epidural with my first and a HORRIBLE experience which included nearly needing a blood transfusion due to too much medical intervention--I went on to have 3 natural childbirths that were all wonderful, fast recoveries, alert babies, and I could pee by myself! I'm not a Nazi about natural childbirth, and I don't like how this issue has the tendency to polarize mothers, but I will say it was a million times better without the drugs for me. I never managed a homebirth--too chicken--but I did have a midwife and no interventions, not even an IV. I think the key is, as others have said, self-education and preparation for the birth that is best for you and your baby. That said, I am completely anti-C-sections that aren't medically necessary.

    I'm looking forward to the rest of the story.

    07.13.09 - 06:17 PM
  • 260. sparkyd said:

    First off I have to say that I can't wait to read the rest of this story; I love birth stories, especially when injected with a good dose of humour and written by people that know how to write a great story! I'm sitting here 3 days overdue with #2, so a very timely subject as well.

    But I'm actually commenting just to throw out a line to other people that might not go the "natural" route to say that that is OK too. You have to do what seems right for you. With #1 my labour came on fast and hard and mother did it ever hurt. I went into the whole thing with a totally open mind, hoping to try to do it without drugs, but OK with going that route if I decided I needed to. Maybe if I had prepared the way Heather did (I read a lot and had an arsenal of breathing techniques and positions etc, but no doula or grand plan) I could have done it, but at 8 cm I asked for the epidural. None of the positions I tried were helping and I was in so much pain I couldn't even think about how to breathe.

    In the end there was a cut and some forceps involved to get my very large son out of my little body, but I was quite happy with that since it meant no c-section after 2 hours of pushing. Besides being completely exhausted, I was very "present" when my son was put in my arms and he started nursing right away. I feel like I received excellent care and I was not cheated out of anything. Maybe my situation is different because my doctor is actually a GP with special training in obstetrics, so kind of mid-way between a mid-wife and an OB. I don't know. I'll be going into my next labour (soon please!!) with the same approach - I'll do what I can without drugs, but I'm not going to beat myself up over it if I end up going that route again. Nor should anyone else.

    07.13.09 - 06:19 PM
  • 261. Holly said:

    Thank you for your humility and honesty in how your worldview about birth was changed and how you advocated for a change in how you wanted to proceed with Marlo's birth. Both very brave and so very appreciated.

    07.13.09 - 06:20 PM
  • 262. C in Canada said:

    Thank you for reminding women that if we did it without epis and shots of friggin' pitocin for thousands of years, we can keep doing it. Our bodies are made to push babies out. And please explain to the world that going without an epidural does not make one a martyr. Oh, and Marlo is gorgeous!

    07.13.09 - 06:22 PM
  • 263. TheFeministBreeder said:

    Welcome to the club.

    I wanted that first baby drug out of me with me not having a millisecond worth of pain.

    Then I went in, got put through the machine, and ended up butchered on an OR table. Thank you Pitocin, Epidurals, and unnecessary cesarean sections.

    The second time I knew better, and I'm happy to say I pushed my baby out the right way, feeling EVERYTHING - and it was the most incredible thing I've ever done in my life.

    Women who don't get to experience it are seriously missing out - and natural birth is just flat out healthier for everyone involved (99% of the time, of course).

    Like Gloria Steinem said - "The truth will set you free, but first, it will piss you off." Women need to get pissed before they realize how the medical system has systematically taken Birth away from them. But then we see the light, and we take it back - one birth at a time.

    07.13.09 - 06:22 PM
  • 264. Mother of another baby Marlowe said:

    I didn't realize that you were planning a natural childbirth. Prior to my first baby, I simiarly started reading about all kinds of childbirth and started to see the patterns that all pointed to how much it made sense to be ambulatory and fully functional during childbirth. I hope that your message will reach many women of childbearing age and will at least open their eyes to the possibiity of natural childbirth. I have now had four babies at home under the care of a midwife and feel the decision to have natural childbirth is probably the single most defining aspect of my life to date....that's how big a deal it is to me.

    My only other advise to you is to not lock yourself into only having two children. I know it's not the right time to even think about that yet... but just keep your mind open.

    07.13.09 - 06:22 PM
  • 265. Jodi said:

    Wow. I never had the option of natural childbirth -- what with the pre-eclampsia with my first and the fact that my 2nd, 3rd and 4th were all on board at once. But I appreciate that you made a plan, then said "This is what I want: a healthy baby." I think too many people get caught up in micro-managing the birth process and feel if it doesn't happen a certain way there's been a failure. One nut job in an internet group I was a part of with my triplet pregnancy had been warned that a vaginal birth would put her multiples at too high a risk (there were suspected anomalies with at least one). Her birth plan was to hide in her house until labor was too far advanced for anyone to deny her the vaginal birth she desired. Way to put your children's health and well-being over your own wants, Screwball!

    But when there's no risk to the child, just like Hannibal from the A-Team said, "I love it when a plan comes together." Hope yours did for you. Can't wait for part II to find out.

    07.13.09 - 06:23 PM
  • 266. Theresa said:

    About halfway through this post I breathed a sigh of relief. I've never read one word that you've written that has ever upset me, until you went on about how crazy people are for having natural births. But who am I to judge? I had the same opinion until I was in the delivery room with a friend and her epidural went horribly wrong. After that I did a ton of research on natural births even though I'm not pregnant *yet*. My husband looked at me like I was crazy when he heard the words "bath tub" and "no epidural". When I said I wanted a doula he said, "medulla oblongata?" and asked if I've been neglecting my armpits lately. He's on board now, but his very conservative mother still thinks I am nuts! Congratulations, I cannot WAIT to read the rest of your birth story!

    07.13.09 - 06:23 PM
  • 267. Marcelle said:

    Congratulations & welcome to the club!! I had both of my girls au natural and it was so empowering. I have no idea how you didn't write about this your entire pregnancy, because I wanted to shout it from the rooftops, but you're sharing now & that's what matters. I can't wait to hear the rest. More details on your "method" please... hypnobirthing, birthing from within, bradley?

    Hypnomom x2,

    Marcelle

    07.13.09 - 06:23 PM
  • 268. Tara said:

    This is EXACTLY what I did - I feel like you just described exactly what I went through. I read Pushed: The Painful Truth About Childbirth and Modern Maternity Care by Jennifer Block. Totally worth reading - it will change how you feel about childbirth entirely.

    07.13.09 - 06:23 PM
  • 269. Erin said:

    I also went through natural child birth, but not really by choice. I only have one child and I had seen my doctor less than 24 hours before giving birth and he told me I had another two weeks to go and what to expect over the next two weeks. So after a night of being in labor at home and only realizing I was in labor 6 or so hours in (yes, it hurt really bad, and no I'm not kidding) I stayed in denial for another three hours until I couldn't stand the pain and woke my husband up to take me to the hospital. LITERALLY 12 minutes after pulling up to the hospital I was holding my daughter. No time for any pain killers. Before giving birth I would have chose the pain killers, now, if I had to go back and do it again, I would do it all natural.

    Good Job Heather!

    07.13.09 - 06:25 PM
  • 270. Amy said:

    I literally squealed with joy for you reading this post. I am not an evangelical natural birther, but I got the sense from earlier posts about us crazy hippies that if you only knew WHY we were so crazy you'd understand. And her you are, with a sacred and spiritual birth experience and I am so happy for you. Women who haven't had that kind of birth don't seem to understand how meaningful birth is. But it is, isn't it? My birth was the most powerful and amazing thing I have ever done in my life, and I can't imagine anything topping it.

    I can't wait for the rest of this story! I'm so excited that such a huge and varied audience gets to read it along with me.

    07.13.09 - 06:29 PM
  • 271. Renee said:

    I really wanted to have a natural birth the first go around, but my doctor was not in delivery the day Moanna was born, so I was forced to have a narcotic, pitocin, epidural filled birth! No one would listen to what I wanted or thought that I could handle it on my own. I will do it drug free next ime

    07.13.09 - 06:30 PM
  • 272. Candice said:

    I am future midwife and a huge, huge advocate of homebirth, so by extension, a huge, huge advocate of drug free births, and I am just pleased as punch that you got to experience it. I am being completely sincere when I say that my heart is swelling with joy right now, knowing that another person has experienced birth the way we were intended to.

    07.13.09 - 06:30 PM
  • 273. Britiney said:

    I had 3 natural childbirths and I too was all "Anyone who would do that is a crazy lunatic" until it came down to me and my body and my baby. The key for me was my doula (a word I'd never heard until halfway through my first pregnancy.) I still get a high every time I think about the birth of my oldest son. I really thought after it was over that I could actually leap tall buildings and negotiate world peace. I was invincible. I wanted to scream out to everyone I saw and say "DID YOU SEE WHAT I JUST DID? I AM A GODDESS!!" Congrats. I hope your doula helps you process what you went through and remember it always.

    07.13.09 - 06:31 PM
  • 274. Lisa in TN said:

    I've given birth six times and every one of them was a heavily medicated,"Okay, I'm 2 cms....where IS the guy with the epidural?!!?!?"

    Now that I'm too old to do it again, you've made me think about the woulda, coulda's. Does that count?

    07.13.09 - 06:33 PM
  • 275. Jill--Unnecesarean said:

    So, yeah. You continue to kick ass.

    07.13.09 - 06:36 PM
  • 276. Lisa said:

    YAY! I can't wait to read the rest! I am a natural childbirth educator and eat this stuff for breakfast, lunch and dinner!

    07.13.09 - 06:41 PM
  • 277. Lisa in NE said:

    At last! I am done with all the Momversation Mommies and their completely closed minds about natural childbirth. I will only read you from now on. My 3 natural births were wonderful experiences...and I'm no hippy. ;-)

    07.13.09 - 06:41 PM
  • 278. New Mama said:

    I love your blog, Heather, but as a homebirth, attachment parenting mother I always felt a bit put off by some of what you write. I NEVER would have guessed you'd change your mind about this...never in a million years. I have SO MUCH more respect for you now, not just that you came to same conclusions I did ;) but that you were willing to change your mind mid-game.

    FWIW I too planned on a hospital birth and at 38 weeks fired my doctor and hired a midwife. My son's birth was the most amazing thing in my life and I could not be prouder of it. Congratulations to you, mama. You rock.

    07.13.09 - 06:44 PM
  • 279. Molly said:

    CLIFFHANGER!!!!!!

    07.13.09 - 06:47 PM
  • 280. Elle said:

    Well wait until you figure out why the crazy hippies homeschool then! Unschooling/natural learning at that!

    07.13.09 - 06:48 PM
  • 281. omchelsea said:

    Oh, I can't wait for the rest of this story! I have a good friend who is a doula and a very good friend who is very worried about my pro-homebirth stance :S but maybe I'll get her some books to read before I fall preggers! Hanging out for the rest of the story!

    07.13.09 - 06:49 PM
  • 282. jana said:

    I'm very, very excited to read this first part...I jumped on the bandwagon about, oh, one week into my first pregnancy and never looked back. Yes, childbirth can be a sacred experience! No, I don't smell like patchouli!

    Couple more great recommendations: Giving Birth by Catherine Taylor, and Baby Catcher by I can't remember...it's about a midwife, though. Both very good.

    07.13.09 - 06:50 PM
  • 283. EOMama said:

    Thank you thank you THANK YOU for writing about natural childbirth, Birthing From Within, The Business of Being Born, etc.! Did I say thank you?! More women need to talk about this. Period. Women have been trained to ignore the wisdom of their bodies and it has gotten us nothing but a 30% c-section rate, and the attitude that c-sections are no big deal. Trust me: they are a BIG FUCKING DEAL. Just ask anyone who's had to recover from one.

    You rock, Heather!

    07.13.09 - 06:50 PM
  • 284. Jennifer said:

    The epidural was so awful, that I just might consider natural birth next time! Seriously. I think I would prefer all that pain to being shot in the spine several times. Makes me cringe just thinking about it.

    07.13.09 - 06:50 PM
  • 285. Kathryn said:

    Woooooo go you! You're a serious birthing rockstar! I can't wait to hear the rest.

    My mother did 4 natural births, and even with one lousy midwife, she says she'd never have it any other way. Apparently I was inverted or some such thing (not breech, but flipped face down or whatever), and anyone who knows anything about childbirth understands how annoyed my mom was that the doctor flipped me over 3 times and I kept turning myself back over! Gah-ross.

    I like to think I'll be able to do it...we'll see!

    07.13.09 - 06:55 PM
  • 286. Olivia said:

    I nearly cried when I read this post. I had a very similar experience. I had an epi with my first child, and went natural with the second. I can't encourage people to hire Doulas enough. Bravo!

    07.13.09 - 06:56 PM
  • 287. C. Beth said:

    My natural labor and childbirth (water birth at midwife-staffed birthing center) was the most spiritual experience of my life. (I'd had an epidural/hospital birth with my first & like you, I changed my tune at some point.)

    I'm so happy for you.

    And I kind of like my Captcha. It's "omelette $17-million." That omelette must contain a boatload of truffles.

    07.13.09 - 06:56 PM
  • 288. Anonymous said:

    oh I'm so proud of you. I have a 10 week old and tried to do it drug free but didn't quite make it. did I mention, though, that he was 9 lbs, 11 oz??? regardless, they let me keep the baby. epidural or not so I'm happy :)

    07.13.09 - 06:57 PM
  • 289. Trisha said:

    I'm am SO HAPPY to read this post! I can't wait to read the whole story!

    I, too, experienced the wonders of natural childbirth. A wonderful and empowering experience!! I now consider myself a "birth junkie." I could talk about birth all day everyday!

    Thank you for sharing your story! You WILL make a difference in the lives (and labors) of hundreds -if not thousands - of women and babies!! Thank you for taking the stigma away from natural birth.

    07.13.09 - 06:58 PM
  • 290. Sunny said:

    I realize that I am nobody of any consequence... but I am pregnant with my third child. My first 2 were both induced (because my OB was going on vacation, both times) and I had an epidural both times.

    I do not want that again... I am wanting a natural childbirth at a hospital. And my husband wigged out when I told him that I didn't want any medication.

    All of this to say, that your story means something to more than you and your family. It is hope for me. That I can do this, even if my entire family thinks I've lost my marbles.

    Thanks for sharing.

    07.13.09 - 07:01 PM
  • 291. sevanetta said:

    Heather, my God, thankyou so much for sharing this. That is so amazing. I have a friend in Australia who's a huge homebirth / drug-free birth advocate (having had a homebirth herself two years ago) and learnt much more about it because of her. Having read your story (I loved your book btw it was awesome, I wanted to read it so much I ordered it to my parents' house in Australia and got them to post it to me in East Timor, totally worth it), I had thought before how it had the signs of maybe-things-don't-have-to-be-like-this.

    In Australia we're battling to stop the government from cutting off insurance for independent midwives for next year - maybe you could drop our health minister a line and tell her this is a bad idea?

    http://www.news.com.au/adelaidenow/story/0,22606,25657523-2682,00.html

    http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/stories/s2501831.htm

    07.13.09 - 07:01 PM
  • 292. FPIESmommy said:

    I love that movie and have had that book on my ready to order list from amazon for a couple weeks now. Will definely purchase soon (to be honest I was waiting to read until I am pregnant again). A couple other ones (I read after I had my daughter and wish I had read before):Birth: The Surprising History of How We are Born by Tina Cassidy, Pushed: The Painful Truth About Childbirth and Modern Maternity Care by Jennifer Block, and Baby Catcher: Chronicles of a Modern Midwife by Peggy Vincent. I had a midwife and a doula but gave birth in the hospital - maybe home next time, we will see how it goes! Can't wait to hear the rest of your story.

    07.13.09 - 07:04 PM
  • 293. Anonymous said:

    Congratulations! I, too, made the conscious decision to have the birth I wanted and did, indeed, accomplish a no intervention, natural waterbirth.

    I'm so glad you ran across material that helped you in the direction I wish more women would even know about, let alone "do".

    07.13.09 - 07:06 PM
  • 294. Meegan said:

    Holy shit. This is NOT what I expected! I cannot wait to hear the rest of this story. I realize you have a lot on your plate right now, but if you could just prioritize finishing your labor story I'd really appreciate it. Feedings, diaper changes, making Leta feel secure and loved, eating, pooping (I hope you are pooping!)...do those things later. They can totally wait. No biggie.

    07.13.09 - 07:06 PM
  • 295. Anna said:

    Oh man, can't wait for the next installment of your birth experience!

    I'm not nearly organized enough to actually plan a birth. So I never tried. Both my kids were induced... daughter had to be born because I was dangerously preeclamptic, son had to be born because he was getting way way past date was not getting any smaller if you know what I'm saying.

    I'm a big fan of pitocin at this point. Labor hurt, sure, but it wasn't scary-painful. I had an epidural with my first and I think that is why I had to push for an hour and a half. I actually tried to get an epidural with my second, but he was coming too fast so I delivered without it, and was I ever glad. It went great. Three or four pushes, no more than 10 minutes, and once he was out all the pain was gone, just like that. Magic!

    Congrats - now tell us the rest!! :)

    07.13.09 - 07:07 PM
  • 296. Lauren said:

    Magical! Congratulations on what sounds like a miraculous realization. It's amazing how these things just pop up out of nowhere. 10 weeks isn't a long time to make a natural birth happen - it's a lot of hard work, and preparing the people around you takes quite a bit of energy (the type pregnant women rarely have). I'm thrilled to hear that Ricki Lake and Abby Epstein's work made such a big impact on you, too. I was quite impressed by it myself.

    07.13.09 - 07:07 PM
  • 297. Ms. Moon said:

    As a woman who has had three home births and who has worked with midwives, let me just say that I am so thrilled that you with your big soapbox, are talking about this.
    There IS a reason women go through childbirth unmedicated. It is simply the most amazing and yes, spiritual experience of a lifetime. There is a reason for the pain and if we take away the pain from a laboring woman, we take away her power. I can say it no more clearly than that and I am so happy to hear that you understand this now.

    07.13.09 - 07:07 PM
  • 298. Theresa said:

    Oh, anyone looking to watch The Business of Being Born, if you have Netflix, you can watch it on your computer! I guess the laundry isn't getting done tonight...

    07.13.09 - 07:09 PM
  • 299. Dorothy said:

    I have been waiting for this post. Every time I show up to the page, I refresh a few times to make sure my browser isn't being lazy and showing a cached page. I can't wait to hear the rest - I don't have children (or a husband, for that matter - minor detail) and love hearing different people's stories, even if sometimes they make me swear off having kids (although something tells me this one will make me want them more).

    BTW, my roommate had a baby and would tell stories about being at work typing away on the keyboard and all of a sudden having the entire front of her soaked from milk. Thank goodness you work from home.

    07.13.09 - 07:11 PM
  • 300. Bari said:

    I was due last week with my first (still waiting) and was also completely inspired by Ricki Lake, although it was prior to my pregnancy so I went with a midwifery practice (delivering in hospital). I feel like you pulled this post from my brain, reworded it all smartly and then typed it out for me.

    Thank you thank you thank you for giving me a little push if you will, a little "YOU CAN DO THIS" because it is so inspiring to hear. being almost 41 weeks pregnant you start to get a little nervous about labor and I already feel like NCB advocates are so in the minority, It is amazing how many people have said to me "you'll just get an epidural" as a way to write off the pain of labor.

    I am not completely out of my mind, I do not like pain, I am not a martyr but it just makes so much sense. Seriously, thank you.

    07.13.09 - 07:11 PM
  • 301. Cheryl said:

    I don't plan to have children, but I saw the Ricki Lake documentary too and thought it was wonderful. The film was tremendously enlightening and I was moved by Ricki's bravery in making it. Thank you for talking about it here--I had noticed that the film was kind of under-reported in the press, and you are so helpful to bring the subject to your audience.

    But what I mostly wanted to say is that I'm so happy to hear that you and Marlo had such a lovely delivery! She is a beautiful little girl, and your family deserved no less than a tranquil birth. Many congratulations.

    07.13.09 - 07:12 PM
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • ›
  • »

You must have a dooce® Community account to leave a comment.

If you've already registered, login.

If this is your first time posting here, snag a free account.

Heather talks about Valentine's Day on today's Momversation.

  • I know zero about sports, but my entire heart is screaming, "Go Saints! Go Saints!" I am a stereotypical woman. TAKE OUT THE GARBAGE, JON!
  • Marlo has a tooth! So says the blood that she drew when she grabbed my hand and tried to gnaw off my thumb!
  • Leta won't eat her birthday cake. I guess we should have made it out of chicken nuggets and iced it with refried beans.


Footer Books by Heather B. Armstrong
It Sucked and Then I Cried by Heather B. Armstrong

It Sucked and Then I Cried

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Other Vendors

Things I Learned About my Dad in Therapy by Heather B. Armstrong

Things I Learned About My Dad in Therapy

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Elsewhere

  • flickr
  • Twitter
  • Recently

    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009

    © 2001 - 2010 Armstrong Media, LLC. All rights reserved. Powered by Drupal. Hosted by Liquidweb. Footer Feedicon RSS Feed Footer FM badge Advertise on dooce®